[beatfreak]

Quote:

Thanks!!!  Wow is it really 140 pages?  I don't remember though I did draft it in MS word.  The HE-400 is a great choice.  I gave it an A+ because, even though there's some headphones with a "purer" tonality, very few headphones are as convincingly immersive and fun

Oh yeah sorry,  I meant I read the review and all 140 pages of comments.

 

[szoze]

This thread is a respectful laboring achievement but unfortunately nothing more than that. I as many other people here don't agree about many conclusions. I also have to point out that a test/review of this kind should be administered using a panel with listeners (at least 10 people) in order for it to be anywhere near objective. Waste of time, IMHO. Please, don't make a PDF.

 

[grokit]

So 10 people would make subjective opinions objective? I disagree, that would just give us a consensus of 10 subjective opinions.

 

[szoze]

Quote:

So 10 people would make subjective opinions objective? I disagree, that would just give us a consensus of 10 subjective opinions.

I never said that it would be an objective opinion, only a less subjective one.

 

[Ryolith]

Quote:

This thread is a respectful laboring achievement but unfortunately nothing more than that. I as many other people here don't agree about many conclusions. I also have to point out that a test/review of this kind should be administered using a panel with listeners (at least 10 people) in order for it to be anywhere near objective. Waste of time, IMHO. Please, don't make a PDF.

First, this review was never meant to be objective to begin with.  He says, "I in no way intend for this review to be perceived as anything more than one audio enthusiast's personal opinion." And as a new Headfier, I found it helpful. Second, he can do whatever he wants to his own thread including making a pdf if he so chooses. So IMHO your comment is a waste of time . thanks

 

[grokit]

Quote:

This thread is a respectful laboring achievement but unfortunately nothing more than that. I as many other people here don't agree about many conclusions. I also have to point out that a test/review of this kind should be administered using a panel with listeners (at least 10 people) in order for it to be anywhere near objective. Waste of time, IMHO. Please, don't make a PDF.

 
Quote:

Quote:

So 10 people would make subjective opinions objective? I disagree, that would just give us a consensus of 10 subjective opinions.

I never said that it would be an objective opinion, only a less subjective one.

 
Let us know when you're done writing up your epic 10-person double-blind headphone comparison with all possible variables accounted for. It should be epic, looking forward to it!
It's great that you'll be contributing something constructive

 

[szoze]

Quote:

First, this review was never meant to be objective to begin with.  He says, "I in no way intend for this review to be perceived as anything more than one audio enthusiast's personal opinion."

 
I know, and that was why I reacted in the first place.
 
Quote:

And as a new Headfier, I found it helpful.

 
Great, but as a new Headfier you shouldn't rely on one person's opinion only (I know you won't)
 
Quote:

Second, he can do whatever he wants to his own thread including making a pdf if he so chooses.

 
Yeah, that is true. It was just my recommendation

 
Quote:

So IMHO your comment is a waste of time . thanks

 
 
I don't think so. I think that many more people should have reacted. But that is just imho.

 

[szoze]

Quote:

 
 
Let us know when you're done writing up your epic 10-person double-blind headphone comparison with all possible variables accounted for. It should be epic, looking forward to it!
It's great that you'll be contributing something constructive

 
The only thing I can say in my defense is to refer to your signature (Plato)

 

[whiteshadow001]

I now really want a pair of hifiman he500's and a pair of beyerdyanmics haha

 

[hifimanrookie]

I now really want a pair of hifiman he500's and a pair of beyerdyanmics haha

I have of both a pair..trust me..u wont regret it ( but pls..do urself a favor and get the right amp fir the he500 also . )

 

[hifimanrookie]

Let us know when you're done writing up your epic 10-person double-blind headphone comparison with all possible variables accounted for. It should be epic, looking forward to it!
It's great that you'll be contributing something constructive

Yep me too am curious what u have in ur mind to atribute contructively concerning 10 person double blinded headphone comparision ( 60 headphones right?).but pls make sure u put it online before i turn 60. Plsss seriously..if u manage that..i bow for u..as it will be epic..never done anywhere..

 

[mcast20]

I was hoping we were all going to be smart enough to ignore him, when someone posts rude comments like that, they are just looking for a reaction. David amazing work, I absolutely love my SE535's but being so low on your list I am now curious and ready to argue with the wife, thanks a lot lol.

 

[Kendoji]

Haha - 10 person panels are, of course, the standard for all audio equipment reviews.  Oh wait, no they're not.  But that's what these forums are for - it's very easy to find more opinions to compare with.  The difference is that most people only have real experience with a limited number of headphones, which is what makes David's overview so unique and interesting.
 
edit: @mcast20 you're quite right (feel guilty now lol).

 

[asdfghjkzxcvbnm]

"The XBA-4 can sound a bit sharp with most popular music"
 
What do you mean by sharp?
 

 

[hifimanrookie]

Quote:

I was hoping we were all going to be smart enough to ignore him, when someone posts rude comments like that, they are just looking for a reaction. David amazing work, I absolutely love my SE535's but being so low on your list I am now curious and ready to argue with the wife, thanks a lot lol.

+1 i agree with u totally with ur first line