Earbuds Round-Up
Nov 7, 2023 at 11:44 AM Post #72,286 of 75,861
Received my FF3S yesterday and have been comparing with the FF3 (I use the crisp foams with these sets). It's probably too early to draw definitive conclusions, but they do sound a little (as in, a smidge, nothing major) different to me, mostly in the bass presentation. The FF3S is still a bassy bud, but it doesn't sound quite as "big" or meaty as the FF3 to my ear. I find it a little more resolving than the FF3. For those who love the FF3 for its authoritative bass, that might be a factor. For me, I think the FF3S might actually suit me a little better, as I find the FF3 a bit much sometimes. The FF3S feels like more of an all-rounder. I've listened to them out of the Amp14 card in my DX320 and out of my RU7 at 128.

In terms of build quality, the FF3S feels a little cheaper to me (it's much lighter than the FF3). The steel of the FF3 gives that sense a substantial feel of quality that the FF3S lacks. On the plus side, this might make it more comfortable for longer sessions. The cable is as annoying as it was on the FF3 and I'm toying with the idea of ordering the FF5-style cable Fiio recently released for the FF3S, though I don't really love that cable either. This is where the proprietary connector is a bummer. And this is purely esthetic, but where the motif on the back of the bud made sense with the silver or black of the original FF3, I don't think it works with the deep blue of the FF3S and, to me, it further cheapens the FF3S. But that's a very subjective thing, obviously.
Huhu thank you for comparison between the two it really relieves me in a big way, also do you have the FF5 by any chance? Because the way you described is kinda similar how people describe the FF5.

And btw to those interested getting their Smabat M5 Pros there's a big voucher drop going on shopee rn ordered mine for only 89 USD. (I couldn't resist lol):L3000:
 
Last edited:
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:05 PM Post #72,287 of 75,861
IMG_9015.jpeg
Venture Electronics Zen SU (Shining Ultimate)

Just received these in the mail. Will give them a proper listen over the next few days and post some initial impressions.

From first listen it’s very mid bass heavy and warm…
Congrats on your new shiny! :)
MY TOP 5 EARBUDS

#1 Cypherus Audio Susvara Black Dragon

The mighty 🐉 fills a huge portion of my library, literally everything in my music library sounds incredible. The deepest most layered sub bass of any Bud I know of! I feel like I’ve gushed enough about this bud.


#2 TGXear Desolation Sound

The man, the myth..The Legend! Mr. Jim Park @tgx78 master of flathead wizardry and painter of mystic landscapes blessed us with his masterpiece and I couldn’t be happier. A wonderful all rounder that excels with classical, modern classical, ambient and modern electronic music. Highly resolving bud! Micro dynamics are 🤌🏼

#3 Venture Electronics APWS or Asura Pure White Shining

This is a specialist in my collection and has the best string timbre I’ve ever heard. Excels with solo and small ensemble classical and female vocals. Not a Bud for pop, rock, or anything with too much energy or a lot going on. This is a timbre/tonality king and meant for intimate listening of the highest pedigree.

#4 TGXear Tantalus

An oldie but a remarkable listen when powered properly. This is a recent discovery as I used to own this bud and I sold it due to hearing it muddy and bloated…Re purchased recently as I have a better DAP with better integrated power and Tantalus sounds like an Aroma Jewel in earbud form. Seductive timbre in male and female vocals. Resolving and sparkling treble. Great Modal Jazz bud!

#5 Venture Electronics Zen SU or Shining Ultimate

This is another new bud in my collection and while it sounds GRAND and oozing with warmth I’m still wrapping my head around it. @ian91 was correct in saying it rocks with music from Tool! This bud has some of the most correct sounding guitar tone (electric and acoustic alike) I’ve heard in any monitor, Bud or headphone! Female vocals are favored here and a calling card I’ve noticed with VE. I def hear a house sound in this flagship bud. I still need to run through my library but it’s already a favorite!

This list is subject to change and/or rearrange :)


Buds I most want to hear:
Yinman 2.0 600ohm
Shozy BK
Puresounds 100-500,600
Ksearphone Bell-Ti+, DBX
Simphonio Dragon 3+
FQL BlueMoon
Yuin PK1
Ucotech Es-P2
Very nice list there. :)

Reading your comments about the APWS, you might also want to add to "want to hear" the Moondrop Chaconne. They are also an oldie (and there is a reason they are still around), but the overall tone on these (and for the same type of music) is simply rare, and the best I have heard to date. The fact that they have a very low quantity of bass keeps them from being good for anything that is not classical, jazz, instrumental (or music with lots of engery) as well. This set proves (to me anyhow) that you can have a boosted treble and mids that are NOT offensive to the ears, and that if there are no dips and peaks, they can be this way while remaining so smooth sounding. Accuracy of tone and grand sound stage are the forte of these winners (IMHO). If you know this going into them, you will not be disappointed, as can be vouched for by any that bought them and still own them. :)
respect-bro-respect-0b747c0962.jpg

Thanks for taking one for the team! Look forward to your impressions man!

Hope this will be the start of Smabat's redemption arc.
Thank you very much. I certainly hope this is indeed a redemption of Smabat. For me, if it isn't I will probably not be purchasing anything from future products from them. At that point I will just live on fondly with the ST10S B&G, and the M2s Pro w/all the driver modules. To me, this is the era of buds from them where they were at their peak in quality to sound. While quality did increase over the years, the sound degraded to nothing more than shouty sound (which as I mentioned was a tragic shame, and a horrible move on their part). I certainly hope that they started actually listening to their audience more.
Are you able to give impressions comparing these to the Yincrow RW-3000?
When I receive mine, I can also give impressions of the comparison of the two. Though, if they are anything like the ST10S B&G, I don't think it will be a comparison so much as they will simply be different (in most ways).
Way to busy lately. Had a long session with SU before I had to remove my listening corner from the living room. Some long overdue refurbish of floor and painting I promised wife 😁 1 week break from hard to drive stuff now.

Zen SU do have much of that rich Zen line sound, with full bass specially mid bass but also some sub. Mids also being in the thicker side.

Don't try with any Tool but I listened to some doom metal and it was very impressive. Actually very similar to FranQL Caelum with just more mid warmth on SU.

Hope you get to try the Blue Moon one day since you love APWS, biggest change for me is that APWS is slightly more bright while the Blue Moon have better textured low range.

The Sun Copper is next in line for me to play with, the short listen it seemed very good also. And the price more easy to justify 😁



Anyway try this on SU, not many buds that suit this type of music and SU do excellent here.

This sounds VERY good on the Yinman 2.0 600 and the Caelum. Both of these buds are detailed enough yet smooth to keep even the most wailing of vocals or guitars from hurting the ears long enough to get the message of the song. :) I use these two for (an assortment of) metal quite frequently.

Good rec BTW! I had not heard of them before you shared. :)
A Silly question
If I have 350mw dongle. What earbud Ohm should I buy? 64ohm, 300ohm, or 600 ohm.
As mentioned, there are too many variables missing here to give a definitive answer. Is the 350mW the max power, or the stated power at 16 or 32ohms? It is fairly likely that the 64ohm variant you mentioned should be able to be driven to full capacity with the dongle, even if the sensitivity is very low, but for the others, I could not venture a guess (let alone an accurate assessment) unless I knew more about both the dongle or the head gear.

Having said that, it is also likely that the 300ohm and 600ohm gear would not be driven well from a 350mW signal, but again, this is also a guess. But, another thing to keep in mind is that even if they can be driven from this dongle, would you want to? The point is that you should look at all the other numbers that factor in to the overall sound makeup. Some might use the generic term "synergy", but you can get a pretty good idea of some of this stuff by looking at those other numbers; though, just like looking at a FR curve, it won't give the full picture.

Things like THD, and DNR, and output impedance, and Crosstalk, and etc... all go together to give you an idea of what the chosen head gear might sound like (or at least how limiting it can be, or things of that nature).
Is it true that 60$ speaker (edifer goodies) can beat 300$ earbud? In sound stage.
Overall, I would say that it is likely true. That is the short answer though, and a bit deceiving on top of that. You MAY have to spend $6000 (for example) to make the room more "acoustically friendly" for those cheap speakers to have better sound stage. Where, with the earbuds, you get this portably, and with the cost that is up front.

Building a "sound room" for loudspeakers is a WHOLE other animal, and the cost can get simply astronomical for those that want it done right. This is only the tip of the iceberg where loudspeakers are concerned too.
It is generally accepted idea that there's nothing going to beat speakers in soundstage but it comes with a caveat needing a somewhat properly treated room and setup
Very true. :) Also, coming from a laptop output will probably NOT get you the sound that you are looking for. Head gear, while being expensive itself, is nowhere near as expensive as it can get to have good quality sound from loudspeaker systems.
I moved from IEM to earbud, now to speaker. Comparing them, iem seems like watching movie in a handphone, earbud a 20 inch tv, and speaker a 40 inch tv. Really easy to get chill with heavily congested tracks like samba or funk jazz.
You should not discount a great set of open back headphones to throw into the mix. While I have heard some few earbuds that can get wider/bigger staging than open backs, generally speaking the open back phones have the innate potential to be bigger more often. Size differences alone make them a bit more scientifically probable that this is likely.

I have some of the biggest (known) stage earbuds on the market, and they are indeed bigger than most all of my other gear, but there are a few out there that companies have tried to match/beat for years. A couple of examples are the Sennheiser HD800 (OG), and the Sennheiser HD700; which are only a very small amount smaller than the HD800.
Received my FF3S yesterday and have been comparing with the FF3 (I use the crisp foams with these sets). It's probably too early to draw definitive conclusions, but they do sound a little (as in, a smidge, nothing major) different to me, mostly in the bass presentation. The FF3S is still a bassy bud, but it doesn't sound quite as "big" or meaty as the FF3 to my ear. I find it a little more resolving than the FF3. For those who love the FF3 for its authoritative bass, that might be a factor. For me, I think the FF3S might actually suit me a little better, as I find the FF3 a bit much sometimes. The FF3S feels like more of an all-rounder. I've listened to them out of the Amp14 card in my DX320 and out of my RU7 at 128.

In terms of build quality, the FF3S feels a little cheaper to me (it's much lighter than the FF3). The steel of the FF3 gives that sense a substantial feel of quality that the FF3S lacks. On the plus side, this might make it more comfortable for longer sessions. The cable is as annoying as it was on the FF3 and I'm toying with the idea of ordering the FF5-style cable Fiio recently released for the FF3S, though I don't really love that cable either. This is where the proprietary connector is a bummer. And this is purely esthetic, but where the motif on the back of the bud made sense with the silver or black of the original FF3, I don't think it works with the deep blue of the FF3S and, to me, it further cheapens the FF3S. But that's a very subjective thing, obviously.
Congrats on your new shiny! :)

I have been waiting to hear this since they came out.. :) Thanks for taking the plunge to own both (if for no other reason than to have the knowledge of if they are same or different).

Honestly, and for me the OG FF3 bass is what made them so very special. Otherwise, they would be just on the average side of sound (IMHO). Because they have a boosted pina gain (enough to become fatiguing after a time), and a relaxed treble presentation, and I guess that would make them a bit boring without the fantastic bass that they have.
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:05 PM Post #72,288 of 75,861
Huhu thank you for comparison between the two it really relieves me in a big way, also do you have the FF5 by any chance? Because the way you described is kinda similar how people describe the FF5.

And btw to those interested getting their Smabat M5 Pros there's a big voucher drop going on shopee rn ordered mine for only 89 USD. (I couldn't resist lol):L3000:
I had the FF5, but sold it recently. Bear in mind that everything I’m about to say is based on memory, which probably isn’t worth much. Still, my impression is that FF3S is somewhere between FF3 and FF5, but much closer to 3 than to 5. I don’t want to overstate the difference between 3 and 3S - 3S is still a very bassy bud and it’s meatier than FF5 and not as extended in the treble.
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:07 PM Post #72,289 of 75,861
Huhu thank you for comparison between the two it really relieves me in a big way, also do you have the FF5 by any chance? Because the way you described is kinda similar how people describe the FF5.

And btw to those interested getting their Smabat M5 Pros there's a big voucher drop going on shopee rn ordered mine for only 89 USD. (I couldn't resist lol):L3000:
The way I am reading it is that is the "crowdfund" pricing, and after November 15, it should go up to the normal price. :)

Can't wait to also hear your impressions on these. Do you own any of the Smabat past product to compare to?
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:13 PM Post #72,290 of 75,861
I had the FF5, but sold it recently. Bear in mind that everything I’m about to say is based on memory, which probably isn’t worth much. Still, my impression is that FF3S is somewhere between FF3 and FF5, but much closer to 3 than to 5. I don’t want to overstate the difference between 3 and 3S - 3S is still a very bassy bud and it’s meatier than FF5 and not as extended in the treble.
Thank you very much! It clear things out for me, it seems that it's going to fit my listening taste much better.
The way I am reading it is that is the "crowdfund" pricing, and after November 15, it should go up to the normal price. :)

Can't wait to also hear your impressions on these. Do you own any of the Smabat past product to compare to?
Oh that's the reason why I'm very surprised when I saw the price I quickly ordered it even tho I'm still waiting for more impressions of it lol, anyways no I don't I was going to order the ST-10S BG but I couldn't find any store both local and online that sells them here it's going to be my first Smabat earbuds haha.

Edit: Sorry if I keep editing my post English isn't my first language and so that others can understand me better
 
Last edited:
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:31 PM Post #72,291 of 75,861
I have a few questions regarding Zen SU:4
1. How is the bass compared to DS? DS is currently the standard for earbud bass for me - from both quality and quantity.
2. Is the tonality warmer than DS like Sun Copper?
3. How is the subbass? I found Sun Copper to be a bit lacking in subbass. Have you heard the SC?
Listening now…

1) All I can say is wait until you hear a Cypherus Audio black dragon…however the DS bass is better balanced. SU leans mid bass heavy

2) much warmer tonality than DS

3) Sub Bass is there but not the focus or emphasis. Best Sub is CAX and then TGX Serratus. Best Balanced bass is DS.

I have not heard Sun Copper…but I’ve had Zen 3.0 SL and some Monks, and now Zen SU. I almost bought a Sun Copper but went straight to the top instead. It seems Sun Dice is a leaner less warm sound…but I assume still has that VE signature smooth tonality that even Apws has.

Zen SU will need power so it doesn’t sound Boomy
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:35 PM Post #72,292 of 75,861
Thank you very much! It clear things out for me, it seems that it's going to fit my listening taste much better.
Hopefully it does indeed. :)
Oh that's the reason why I'm quite surprised when I saw the price I quickly ordered it even tho I'm still waiting for more impressions of it lol, anyways no I don't I was going to order the ST-10S BG but I couldn't find any store both local and online that sells them here it's going to be my first Smabat earbuds haha.
Yeah, I can't seem to find them (ST10S B&G) anymore on Aliexpress. I am sure there is probably SOMEWHERE you can still get (leftover) stock, but at this point it seems as though Smabat has finally discontinued them. These have been around for quite some time for Smabat (about 3 years or so), but I suppose they needed to move on to newer stuff. :)
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:45 PM Post #72,293 of 75,861
Way to busy lately. Had a long session with SU before I had to remove my listening corner from the living room. Some long overdue refurbish of floor and painting I promised wife 😁 1 week break from hard to drive stuff now.

Zen SU do have much of that rich Zen line sound, with full bass specially mid bass but also some sub. Mids also being in the thicker side.

Don't try with any Tool but I listened to some doom metal and it was very impressive. Actually very similar to FranQL Caelum with just more mid warmth on SU.

Hope you get to try the Blue Moon one day since you love APWS, biggest change for me is that APWS is slightly more bright while the Blue Moon have better textured low range.

The Sun Copper is next in line for me to play with, the short listen it seemed very good also. And the price more easy to justify 😁



Anyway try this on SU, not many buds that suit this type of music and SU do excellent here.

When you can check out this album on Zen Su

IMG_9020.jpeg

Tomb Mold - The Enduring Spirit
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 12:53 PM Post #72,294 of 75,861
Hopefully it does indeed. :)

Yeah, I can't seem to find them (ST10S B&G) anymore on Aliexpress. I am sure there is probably SOMEWHERE you can still get (leftover) stock, but at this point it seems as though Smabat has finally discontinued them. These have been around for quite some time for Smabat (about 3 years or so), but I suppose they needed to move on to newer stuff. :)
Hopefully move on a better tuning too haha jokes aside smabat makes very capable drivers
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 1:41 PM Post #72,296 of 75,861
Hopefully move on a better tuning too haha jokes aside smabat makes very capable drivers
:wink:

Yes they do indeed. One of my DIY sets that has deeper and more quantity of bass than a lot of my IEMs is made from the Smabat 150ohm TI driver from the M2s Pro set. It is absolutely fantastic sounding (when I am in the mood for a bass blast). It has all that deep and textured bass (including quite a bit of sub bass rumble), while remaining clear in the mids and treble region. This is a bass-head set for sure, and while I normally don't go in for bass heavy sets (anymore), there are times I DO still want to hear this sort of tuning; I also bought the CCA CRA, CRA+ and 7Hz Legato for the same reason, if that tells you anything.

The point is that if you start with a great driver (like this one for example), there is pretty much nothing that can't be accomplished in the end with them. And there are very few faults with this era of drivers (M2s Pro modular drivers). I just don't think that Smabat utilized them properly.

I am still a bit concerned with the M5 modular design that they aren't getting the full potential. There is just no room directly behind the transducer in the shell. Let's hope that the labyrinth design is enough. I am looking at the M4 here, because for me it was the biggest disappointment. It was (IMHO) the best looking bud they have made, but the thinnest and most shouty that I have heard to date also. None of the drivers sound much different to me because there is no room to breathe behind the shell. Keep in mind that I had/have not heard the ST20 or Pro, which I have heard are actually worse in this regard (and having 1 BA probably only exacerbated the issue).

Having said all of that, the ST10S B&G (as well as the M2s Pro with the right drivers; 150ohm TI and 100 Bio SO) were some of the best sounding Smabat buds because while they WERE also boosted at 3K (or so), there was plenty of bass to spare to offset that, and even my (sensitive to that region) ears could handle it. :)

Bottom line here (in my train of thought) is that I don't think it has EVER been the drivers that has been at fault with Smabat products. It has always been the shells at fault, though the ST10S went a LONG way towards doing things right IMO... :)

20220830_113956.jpg

20220901_090427.jpg
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 1:48 PM Post #72,297 of 75,861
Hi! Is there an earbuds shell larger than the MX500 shell? Particularly interested in a size of the stem part. It's for DIY purposes so I'm in search of a DIY shell or cheap earbuds to scavenge.
There's this new Huayunxin shell that has a very big back (very pricey tho) and DP100 shells has pretty big and long stem but less superior than MX500 shell when it comes to venting/tuning
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 1:49 PM Post #72,298 of 75,861
Hi! Is there an earbuds shell larger than the MX500 shell? Particularly interested in a size of the stem part. It's for DIY purposes so I'm in search of a DIY shell or cheap earbuds to scavenge.
As for the transducer that it can hold, there are larger, but as for stems, are you talking about wider, longer, more offset???? I am not sure (overall) there is something that has larger stems if looking at them as an overall size (at least not readily available). I think that the classic DP100 shell (for example) is a bit longer, but it is thinner, and less of an offset (from the transducer part) than the MX500 shell.

Having said that there are a few here (such as @ValSuki ) who 3d print their own shells, and could probably come up with something like what you are looking for if the MX500 isn't large enough for you.
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 2:01 PM Post #72,299 of 75,861
:wink:

Yes they do indeed. One of my DIY sets that has deeper and more quantity of bass than a lot of my IEMs is made from the Smabat 150ohm TI driver from the M2s Pro set. It is absolutely fantastic sounding (when I am in the mood for a bass blast). It has all that deep and textured bass (including quite a bit of sub bass rumble), while remaining clear in the mids and treble region. This is a bass-head set for sure, and while I normally don't go in for bass heavy sets (anymore), there are times I DO still want to hear this sort of tuning; I also bought the CCA CRA, CRA+ and 7Hz Legato for the same reason, if that tells you anything.

The point is that if you start with a great driver (like this one for example), there is pretty much nothing that can't be accomplished in the end with them. And there are very few faults with this era of drivers (M2s Pro modular drivers). I just don't think that Smabat utilized them properly.

I am still a bit concerned with the M5 modular design that they aren't getting the full potential. There is just no room directly behind the transducer in the shell. Let's hope that the labyrinth design is enough. I am looking at the M4 here, because for me it was the biggest disappointment. It was (IMHO) the best looking bud they have made, but the thinnest and most shouty that I have heard to date also. None of the drivers sound much different to me because there is no room to breathe behind the shell. Keep in mind that I had/have not heard the ST20 or Pro, which I have heard are actually worse in this regard (and having 1 BA probably only exacerbated the issue).

Having said all of that, the ST10S B&G (as well as the M2s Pro with the right drivers; 150ohm TI and 100 Bio SO) were some of the best sounding Smabat buds because while they WERE also boosted at 3K (or so), there was plenty of bass to spare to offset that, and even my (sensitive to that region) ears could handle it. :)

Bottom line here (in my train of thought) is that I don't think it has EVER been the drivers that has been at fault with Smabat products. It has always been the shells at fault, though the ST10S went a LONG way towards doing things right IMO... :)


Those are mighty looking buds I really appreciate your insights while listening to music I hope I don't have to do some modifications to mine just to be able to enjoy em haha
 
Nov 7, 2023 at 2:01 PM Post #72,300 of 75,861
Reading your comments about the APWS, you might also want to add to "want to hear" the Moondrop Chaconne. They are also an oldie (and there is a reason they are still around),
This one has been in my
Saved for later cart on Amazon for quite some time. I love the look of them but have been worried I wouldn’t gel with the Sound. Thank you for your impressions. I have added them to my Buds I Most want to hear list 🙌🏼
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top