Just a note, I have not bought any tubes from that particular guy, but when I got my second pair of NU VT-99, I did think it was a bad pair at first. I listened for maybe an hour, some horrible harshness, a bit of screeching, so I just put them away, was disgusted with the purchase. However, I wanted to give them 10 hours or so before I returned them, and I have since passed that 10 hours, and they are doing just fine. A lot of the bad things just went away with another hour or 2, and now, they are near dead silent. I will say, the pins are a bit picky, I have to move one of them around a bit, otherwise it finds a way to induce some scratching sounds.
To be expected with very old tubes though. So give the NU a bit of time before you judge them. You might have also really gotten a bad batch. No matter what quality anything is, there is always a bad one or 2 when you make a ton of it.
edit: Very jealous of your collection Tony. Glad you are getting the elrogs
Very interested to see which of the NU or TS you prefer with them.