Before I start, I would like to thank Mad and all the other people who have contributed to make this guide so informative. I have read through most of the guide and the last few pages of comments here and want to lay my thoughts out to make sure I understand everything I've read and that I am buying the right stuff! I've been lurking here for a few months now and this is my first post.
I currently have an Xbox One and am using the older Tritton AX720s for surround-sound gaming. The front is pictured below, the rear has the power plug, a "Voice to PS3" port and the optical port that connects to my Xbox One. I include this because, if in understand correctly, this box is unable to accommodate anything other than my Trittons. I am hoping someone can confirm this or, if not, tell me how I could go about hooking up other headphones to this device.
I am pretty happy with the Trittons but am thinking about upgrading to something a little newer. Initially I had my eyes on the new wireless A50s but am now rethinking that after seeing this guide and reading what other people have been saying regarding the relative quality of the A50s compared to their $300 price tag. From what I can tell, the only real benefit from the A50s for me right now would be the lack of wires (which is a big plus). I am now thinking about getting the Phillips Fidelio X1s, an amp and a V-Moda Boom Mic instead. My rationale is that with the X1s I get a set of cans that will work for more than just gaming and blow the A50s away in terms of performance. The downside is that I am still stuck with some cord mess, but hey, you have to pick your battles
Here is where my questions start. From what I can tell, I am going to need some sort of mixamp to convert/mix the surround sound as an intermediary between my Xbox and my headphones. I am also going to need a mic (the vmoda) an amp (looking at the Fio e11 or e12), an optical cable and a 2.5-3.5mm cable, i think. Is this correct? I am a bit unsure if I need the amp when using the X1s, but from what I can tell even if they don't need it it will only help them perform better, both for gaming and just listening to music in general.
I had hoped to be able to use my Tritton box but I don't think I will be able to do that, as there is not a headset jack from what I can tell. (Maybe someone will show me otherwise!). So, I need a mixamp. From what I have read, the Astro Mixamp 5.8 is a decent place to start. Trouble is I am not exactly sure which version of the 5.8 I am supposed to be getting. The guide mentioned a new and old version, stating that the older the better is preferable. I have no idea how I am supposed to tell what Mixamp 5.8 will work for my needs! I don't want to end up buying the wrong thing, lol. This is probably what I am most confused on right now. I think I have picked out a good amp, mic and pair of headphones (the X1s), so I just need to figure out what sort of mixamp I need as my intermediary, whether it is the Astro setup or something else (other suggestions welcome)!
Any help or advice on either tracking down the proper Astro Mixamp 5.8 or on another mixamp solution would be greatly appreciated. Right now the X1s are going for $250-300. In addition to the headphones, I am ready to spend around $150 extra on the mixamp, amp and mic to make the X1s function for gaming as well, just to give everyone an idea of my budget.
Oh, and as a closing bit, do you guys think this setup is a good choice overall? I listen to a lot of music, especially while studying, and I have 3 years of living, gaming and studying alone in law school ahead of me next fall. I currently have V-Mada LP2s as my go-to cans but they are two years old and beat to hell, which is why they are my on the go pair for traveling, walking around, going to class, etc. I occasionally listen to Bose AE2s and as I said before I have my Trittons for gaming. I think my proposed X1 setup makes sense for me, since the X1s will work for gaming and general listening at home or in the office. If people think there is a better solution I am more than open to hearing their thoughts