It's odd that my findings with the GZ34, GZ37 and 596 seem to differ from general consensus. With Tung Sol BGRP, GEC 6AS7 and HD800, I didn't like the GZ34 (both black and metal base) much. I found them rather bright with a small soundstage. With 6F8G drivers they sound great though, but it's odd that the electrically equivalent 6SN7s don't seem to play nice with the GZ34 in my system. I'm tempted to sell them, but I keep thinking that I'll find a great tube combo for them in the future.
The skinny GZ37 was somewhat meh to my ears, decent but nothing outstanding. The fat bottle version is a different beast altogether that has a fantastic cozy, tubey feel. It's my favourite indirect-heated rectifier by far.
I find the 596 to be a great all-rounder with few glaring weaknesses. It has a good blend of wide soundstaging, warmish tones, slightly forward presentation and fast dynamics. In fact, it has been residing in my Woo for a few months already and I don't feel the urge to rotate it out.