A short announcement from the guy that brought you the giant killer SHE3580
So guys, I'll be busy for the next few days and dropping off the radar for a while. Before I leave I thought I'd throw this out and see where it sticks... the Philips SHE9620
9620 (gold) 9621 (purple) 9622 (black)
Like Dsnuts I was curious about exploring other Philips and got these for $25 but apparently they can be had for anywhere from $10 to $15... in gay translucent gold or purple or manly black
The only thing the store got was purple so that's what I got
I've analyzed them on my parametric equalizer. Here, take a look at how they sound to me:
Firstly here's how the SHE3580 sounds like to me. (I took my parametric EQ settings and inverted them, it becomes a frequency response graph of sorts.) ie a bass hump extending all the way down to the audible extreme, with peaky treble (which as I mentioned is to some extent unavoidable in earphones due to ear canal resonance)
Here's how the SHE9620 sounds like to me. Bass is pretty much the same as the SHE3580 (with perhaps a tad less strong subbass below 40Hz; not shown on the graph), but treble is literally smoother, with only two peaks instead of four. The number of treble peaks could be used as an objective measure of out-of-the-box unEQed treble quality; I profiled the Etymotic ER-4P and they had just one treble peak. There's also less treble in quantity compared to the SHE3580.
I would like to post more conventional sonic impressions ("on yada yada song the cymbals sounded like yada and the vocals sounded like bada") but I'm pressed for time and the above characterizes the difference between them to my ears quickly. Suffice it to say that I only spent one morning creating the EQ profile for the 9620 and I like what I hear so far and the EQ profile is less peaky and less hilly, possibly meaning even better sonic quality than the SHE3580 for those who don't EQ. I do wonder if the lowered treble quantity will be the undoing of these for some though, because I don't hear many people complaining of overbright highs on the SHE3580, so less treble could mean dull treble for them, especially next to the strong bass. Certainly if you're one of those few complaining of bright highs on the 3580 the 9620 could be for you
Oh, and for those of you complaining about the build of the SHE3580, the 9620 is built really nice, with nice thick tangleproof 'clothy' cable, chin slider, and a nice padded pouch to put them in
Anyway, have more cheap-fi fun!