Kiwi Ears Aether vs Letshuoer S12 (2024)
This was the comparison I left until the last second, before the Aether has to go to the next lucky fella. So the two albums chosen for the comparo would be :
Kaisa's Machine - Taking Shape
Esperanza Spalding - Esperanza
A wide array of instruments, as well as vocals.
Bass : The bass is very interesting. So you'd think the Aether's bass is fuller, punchier, and more impactful than the S12 (2024), but this is NOT the case. The bass is warmer, more rumbly in the sub bass, and more impactful in the mid bass, BUT the bass of the Aether is more textured, note resolute, and cleaner, with a quicker snap. It's also a deeper bass, with more spaciousness, and dimensionality than the flatter bass response of the S12. So the bass comes off as fuller and cleaner on the Aether, while the S12 is slower, warmer, but with more impact on both mid bass and sub bass, while the Aether let's you hear the details in the bass, with uncanny note resolution and incisiveness that the S12 just can't provide with it's thicker presentation.
Midrange : Here we have a 3D, spacious, and immersive stage and midrange spatial cues with the Aether. It's what jumps out at you immediately when you listen to both these IEMs with an a/b, is the immersive and expansive stage you are greeted with, while the S12 (2024) is more intimate, with a thicker, more musical midrange, that's maybe a 1/2 step behind in overall incisiveness and resolution. It's a warmer, darker midrange, that though details are present and can pop, it's not at the level of the clean, clear, and more transparent midrange floor of the Aether. That's probably the best descriptors (transparent and technical vs musically lush and warm). While the S12 isn't quite as warm and lush as say the Letshuoer S08, it's fairly close, and actually has better detail retrieval than the S08, but nowhere near the technical skills of the Aether. Same with instrument separation and imaging. It's spacious and technical with the Aether, and more intimate and emotive with the S12, so vocals, both male and female, carry more emotion, weight, and texture with the S12 (2024), vs the more clinical and dry approach of the Aether. So you'd pick up throaty warm with vocals in the S12, while you'd hear the vibration of a drier voice with the Aether. A wisp vs a whisper. Upper mids are both smooth and devoid of shout or peaks in the Aether and the S12. So anyone who's sensitive in that area can rest easy knowing they won't get bleedy ear with either IEM, but as mentioned earlier, the resolution and crispness is just a touch more impressive with the Aether, making it less warm and a bit clearer.
Treble : The Aether is clearly more incisive, extended, and airy. While the S12 (2024) treble isn't rolled off, and the Aether not strident, there's just a more defined resolution and crispness to the Aether that makes it's treble refined, natural, and airy, while still maintaining a fair bit of smoothness. so it never gets strident or peaky. The S12 has very rounded notes, slightly reigned in upper harmonics, and though it can be defined as airy, it lacks a bit of resolution, so those rounded notes provide a less perceivable crispness and extension than the Aether, so though the texture and refinement of the treble is very similar on both, you still get the sensation that the Aether is slightly more resolving and crisp, so making for a more exciting and high def top end, so if you have severe sensitivities in that area, the safer bet for you would be the S12 (2024), though in reality, the Aether treble isn't offensive in the least, but if you want to play it safe...
Stage : Aether in a slam dunk. Not much to discuss here that wasn't discussed earlier. Aether has a fuller, more dimensional space, with superior spatial cues, so that you get an immersive sonic experience, with a large, expressive, and expansive stage. The S12 (2024) is full and warm, with average to slightly above average dimensionality, but next to the Aether, is downright intimate feeling. Say the difference between the stage of the Koss Porta Pro vs the Sennheiser HD600. The Porta Pros don't necessarily have a small stage, but if compared to the HD600, it's going to seem much more intimate than it really is, comparative speaking. The planar driver of the Aether is also larger than the S12 (2024), plus it has a much larger shell, so that probably helps with the expansiveness.? This also makes the S12 a more comfortable fit for longer sessions than the Aether, especially for those with smaller ear holes. I had no issues with comfort with the Kiwi Ears Aether, and the S12 (2024) can have tricky fit with it's very short nozzles, but Penon Black lickies can sold that puzzle fairly well.
Advantage :
Kiwi Ears Aether, but to be honest, I also love the musical warmth of the S12 (2024), and it's also much easier to drive, with the S12 able to be driven by a smartphone or untethered Sony DAP, while this just isn't the case with the Aether. Not at all. The S12 (2024) is one of the easier to drive planars, and unless you want that broad, technically refined and punchy approach of the Aether, you can get away with a great listening experience with the S12 (2024) by Letshuoer. Whether you need the Aether or not if you already have the S12 (2024) is up for debate? You choose.