ljokerl
Portables Reviewerus Prolificus
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2009
- Posts
- 10,274
- Likes
- 975
Quote:
Legacy, mostly. When I started out every category had the same weight including sound. Over time the scale of the 'sound' score got more specific and I increased the weight of the category. I never bothered to change anything else. I've been meaning to halve the weight of the accessory score in the average but it hasn't been high on my priority list. Aside from 'boosting' things like the Phonak Perfect Bass the change really only modifies the order slightly.
Quote:
I don't think it's the 5/5 score that bob has an issue with but the weighting of the category in general. Agreed on the cable - AFAIK the 232 is the first IEM to include both a mic cable and a standard one, something portable headphone manufacturers have been doing for a while.
And thanks, much appreciated
Quote:
In its price range. The GR06 is not as clear and detailed as an RE0 or Sunrise Xcape but still above average for its price. The treble is a bit uneven, not as bad as a Klipsch S3/S4 or anything.
Quote:
Thanks
Quote:
The only place where anything is calculated is the 'average' column of the table, and that's really only used for sorting.
I'm curious why accessories are given the same relative weight in the scoring as comfort, build quality, isolation, etc. I mean, let's be realistic - I have half a dozen of the little earwax tools & clam-shell cases. I also have lots of tips that I never plan on using because they don't fit or are uncomfortable. I get that having multiple sizes of tips can be important - but I think that could simply be a small part of the "comfort" and "sound" categories - I wouldn't have it be a stand-alone metric.
Sorry - I know I'm being critical of what was clearly a HUGE amount of work. I do appreciate your dedication to our hobby!
Legacy, mostly. When I started out every category had the same weight including sound. Over time the scale of the 'sound' score got more specific and I increased the weight of the category. I never bothered to change anything else. I've been meaning to halve the weight of the accessory score in the average but it hasn't been high on my priority list. Aside from 'boosting' things like the Phonak Perfect Bass the change really only modifies the order slightly.
Quote:
I think in case of the PFE232 that's easily justifiable, I've never seen a more complete accessory package with any IEM, tuning filters, replaceable inline mic/remote cable and all.
@Joker: thanks for another great review!
I don't think it's the 5/5 score that bob has an issue with but the weighting of the category in general. Agreed on the cable - AFAIK the 232 is the first IEM to include both a mic cable and a standard one, something portable headphone manufacturers have been doing for a while.
And thanks, much appreciated
Quote:
dear ljokerl. i am going to purchase the Gr06. and have a question about its detail and clarity : is it very good or just good in its price range. and this GR06 is a bit sibilant or much sibilant ?
thank you very much for all of this
In its price range. The GR06 is not as clear and detailed as an RE0 or Sunrise Xcape but still above average for its price. The treble is a bit uneven, not as bad as a Klipsch S3/S4 or anything.
Quote:
Thanks again. I really get a good sense of character from your reviews.
Thanks
Quote:
I don't think |Joker| uses the score for anything. It's just a score, none of it is weighted. If he did weight it equally, he would have some sort of overall score that averaged all of them. I'm sure if he did this, he would not weight accessories as much. I don't even score accessories. I just state what it comes with
The only place where anything is calculated is the 'average' column of the table, and that's really only used for sorting.