Hi! I'm looking for something to replace my ancient (and discontinued) Sennheiser EH350's: http://www.headphone.com/headphones/sennheiser-eh-350.php
No major issues with the sound, but they're horribly uncomfortable without putting foam over the drivers, and they're so old that the paint is peeling off the headband. So then...
Budget: Not more than $150. Preferably on Amazon (gift card monies).
Isolation: Would be nice, but not completely necessary. They'd be mostly for home use. No interest in IEMs.
Source: Laptop, unamped, unless buying an amp or DAC is deemed essential and not over-budget.
Signature: Neutral/flat, or close to it. I don't really want something excessively "colored" or tailored to specific kinds of music (even if that makes them less "fun"...no need to make bad files sound good). Not a basshead.
Possibilities:
Sennheiser HD 380: The only ones I've actually tried. People here seem to have iffy opinions about it, especially the comfort, but my ears (which stick out almost 3cm) actually fit in them, and they don't seem tight to me (small head). They sounded much better than the HD 280's at the same store. Expensive, but Amazon has a refurbed version for ~$100. Doesn't seem durable (plastic, lots of thin moving parts).
KRK KNS 6400/8400: Probably the best in terms of sound, but I'd probably have to pad them to prevent ear pain, which could make them sound worse (?). General opinion seems to be that 8400's sound is better, but not by much (and it depends a lot on the earcups), and it looks harder to drive (0.139 volts for 90dB versus 0.091 for the lesser model).
Shure SRH-440/840: Supposedly a bit bassy? Their prices seem to fluctuate wildly. 440 would probably be unusable for me without buying the 840's pads.
Creative Aurvana Live!: Also supposedly "warm." But I don't really know if that's a bad thing. Quite a few reports of breakage, but at least it's the cheapest option...
NVX XPT100: Apparently a Fischer FA-003 / Brainwavz HM5 clone. The cups are of sufficiently ridiculous size, but it seems to me that they must be amped. Whoever named these sure likes the letter X.
Thanks!