Quote:
Originally Posted by silverknit3 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
After having my tennis bag stolen, with my rackets, Sony A818 and UM2's (total of $800) I've finally recouped and I think after I save up a bit I might get myself a pair of W3's. I was happy with my UM2 but if the W3 is mouth droppingly amazing I might as well save the extra 100 and buy that? What do you guys think? I've got a ton to save up so I have time to make my decision.
|
If there's any way to try the W3s first, I would highly recommend it. I would also think about what you liked about the UM2s.
I upgraded from UM2s, to W3s. I sold the UM2s, so my opinions of the sound are from memory and won't be too detailed. As far as sound quality goes I feel it was a definite upgrade (easily worth $100). I've had no sibilance issues with either IEM. Bass is definitely fuller and more textured with the W3s. I feel like midrange is just slightly less prominent with the W3s, and highs are basically the same. The W3s get better and better the more I listen to them, but I felt that about the UM2s as well.
One of the things I liked most about the UM2s was their design. They fit me perfectly. I didn't have to fuss with different tips (used shure olives). The cable was fantastic, and they just "dissappeared" in my ears after a few minutes. No discomfort, no itchiness, no fiddling around to get the fit just right. To me the W3s are a step down in that aspect. The thicker body, and shorter nozzles make a good fit a little more difficult to achieve and maintain. Tip selection is really important with the W3s. They get a little itchy, and they are just a tiny bit too thick to wear when I'm laying in bed on my side. They do have the same great cable, so that is a wash.
To me the sound quality upgrade was totally worth it. But, if I had never heard them, I wouldn't miss them and would be perfectly satisfied with UM2s (head-fi hype aside).
One other note, I use the W3s with a 2nd generation iPod touch, unamped, so the synergy with your source might be different.
I don't think you can go wrong either way, but hopefully my impressions are helpful for you.
Thanks!
George