Quote:
[size=medium]
Hi Joe,[/size]
[size=medium]
Thank you for your response. Yes, I do wear IEMs on stage now. I have tried the Klipsch S4ii, a couple pairs that were a little more expensive but no more effective and a pair of Sony’s with over the ear clips that I don’t see the model type on them. I currently use the Sony’s because they stay on the best. I am not opposed to sticking with IEMs vs CIEMs but here are my primary issues with the IEMs that I have tried so far. [/size]
- [size=medium]All of them, except for the Sony’s get pulled loose (partially and/or completely) while I play and since our drummer uses a Roland Digital drum set, I can’t hear the drums without having the phones on. I do use cord clips that does help a bit but not well enough.[/size]
- [size=medium]The louder the crowd gets the less I can hear the band in the IEMs. This causes me to turn up the volume to points that are very uncomfortable. This is worse with the Sony’s because they don’t seal well to begin with.[/size]
- [size=medium]After I turn up the volume to counter the increasing room volume, sounds feel like they smash together and picking one instrument out of the whole gets very difficult for me.[/size]
[size=medium]
So those are the primary issues: Needing to turn up the volume to counter room noise and pulling loose. While I like the idea of those models being less than 500, I don’t want to skimp and be left with an ineffective pair or monitors. In my experience you rarely get more than you pay for J[/size] If they will work; that would be awesome too as I love good value! The key word there being Value.
[size=medium]
What am I looking for in an in-ear monitor: [/size]
- [size=medium]something that I will be able to disseminate between the various instruments[/size]
- [size=medium]something that stays in,[/size]
- [size=medium]keeps the outside noise out, [/size]
- [size=medium]be able to hear the drummer and my bass,[/size]
- [size=medium]be able to turn down the volume and still hear the bass and drums when playing in less noisy environments (solo practice)[/size]
[size=medium]
So there you have it; I want a unicorn J[/size]
It seems like everything you have tried will be quite different than CIEMs in the 500 price point. If you can handle the S4, which has a less than smooth treble, (and from what I know the S4ii changes are build quality related), then you should be able to handle treble of something like the Audio Earz aud-5X.
But before I get too far ahead of myself, let me address your second set of bullet points.
- All CIEMs I have heard will separate instruments much better than what you have used. Balanced armature drivers are very good at that!
- CIEMs stay in quite well, at least when a proper fit is achieved
- Silicone is the best for that, but acrylic is also better than most universals.
- If you choose the right model (something with bass capability), you should be able to hear everything clearly.
- CIEMs should allow you to do this no problem
Essentially, what you have described is what CIEMs do!
OK, now for some recommendations with reasoning:
aud-5X - I think the aud-5X has an exceptional price/performance ratio and the bass is very capable. Plus, Mitch will bend over backwards for you, he is great and an active musician (drummer). The 7X might be another option as it has mids and treble like the ES5, but bass like the 5X as it uses 3 bass drivers.
ACS T2 - I am very impressed with the T1 Live!, and have read good things about the T2. The shell is silicone, so it will offer more isolation than acrylic. High price for a dual ($800)
Sensaphonics - I demoed the 2-max and 3-max and thought the 2-max was better. The key to my recommendation here is the silicone shell, which will isolate very well, plus, from my experience. But, the 2-max has a steep price for a dual driver ($850).
Alclair - Marc from Alclair is great and offers exceptional value. His Reference was well reviewed by myself and joker, and he has many other monitors. He is very friendly and would be happy to help you figure out which model of his best fits your needs.
1964 V3 - joker has reviewed the V3 and I believe there is a comparison between the V3 and Alclair Reference. I really can't comment too much since I don't own them.
Ambient Acoustics AM4 - I reviewed the AM4 pro, which is more neutral than the AM4, and it performed stellar for the price, but they are in the Ukraine.
With what I listed, the decision comes down to how much you want to spend, and what is more important to you, ultimate isolation from silicone with good performance or better performance with a bit less isolation. You can ask the companies that make acrylic shelled CIEMs to fill the canal for a bit more isolation as well as making the canal longer.
There are universals that are in the price range of some of the lower end CIEMs, but the isolation probably won't be as good, and for me comfort is much better with CIEMs.
If you can wait until NAMM and if you can get in, you can demo Sensaphonics, UE, Westone, and a few others.
Quote:
This might be a long shot but can anyone compare the 1964 Q and the Rooth LS4. I read joe's impression of the LS4 demo and it sounds interesting, I also heard the Q demo a few days ago and really enjoyed it but I'm wondering which is the better all rounder.
I don't think anyone on here has the LS4, but I would guess it is slightly brighter than the Q, but without hearing both I can't say for sure.
Quote:
I don't know if Cosmic Ears has been mentioned much in this thread, but they are certainly worth taking a look at (particularly for the european members). I posted the below in the main CE thread but figured it would be worth repeating here :-
"Well for some reason getting customs has been a massive (and I do mean MASSIVE)pita for me personally. First there was Fisher (inearz), then Minerva. Both tried and failed to varying degrees (I won't bore you with the details, if your that bored you can look up the relevant threads if you like!). For some reason my right ear (and anyone who knows me should know that that shouldn't be a surprise!) has been the cause of massive problems for me. Phil and Cosmic Ears have gone above and beyond for me. Whilst I still do not have a set of customs progress is slowly but surely being made. I just wanted to give a big thanks in this thread. Other companies could also take a leaf out of Cosmic Ears attitude towards the email address as well!
Here's wishing a merry christmas and a prosperous new year to everyone at Cosmic Ears. Let's hope they have a really successful 2013
".
For anyone not sure about customs or don't want to spend too much (ha!) then these could be a great alternative.
Cheers
Thanks for sharing and I hope you end up with something that works for you and you like.