I tested different songs from different bands & albums and compared sibilance between SR60i and Magnum V4's. Please note, the Magnum V4's only show sharp sibilance on some recordings, so I do understand that much is to blame with the recording in many cases. That is to say, on well recorded music, the Magnum V4's are just great! But when with less than great recordings the SR60i shows really behaved and even enjoyable sibilance and the Magnum V4's shred the recording apart, I have to wonder if the blame is more with the recording or more with the drivers I have.
On a number of songs I tested and confirmed the sibilance is fine with SR60i but razor sharp on the Magnum V4's. I also tested on my iPod Classic, as it's my only other source besides my desktop setup (NFB 15.1) and my Macbook Air. The issue didn't dissolve with a change in source.
Am I being unrealistically expectant of the Magnum V4's to be as forgiving as the SR60i is with music? I always thought the SR60i was fairly revealing of poorly recorded music. Maybe it's more forgiving than revealing. Also note, I use my SR60i with L-Cush, which if anything makes sibilance more present.
My case song is Cry Thunder by DragonForce, off their newer album. On my SR60i the sibilance is behaved, non-distracting, and non-painful. On the HE-400 that I had for a while and then returned, there was no issue with sibilance with this song. Same goes with the HD600 I had for a short time, but that is a somewhat forgiving headphone as I understand it. But, this song on the Magnum V4's is glaringly sibilant. I know it's not exemplary as far as recording quality goes, but this song is an archetypal example of the sibilance issue I am encountering.
As for trying another set of drivers, that very well may happen soon. My situation was such that I ordered the Magnum V4 Build from Turbulent Labs, only to find out the very next day that Rhydon would be supplying Turbulent Labs with his new Magnum drivers. I felt a bit slighted by the seller of the Magnum V4 Build, who knew well that the new drivers were coming but failed to inform me of that. I suspect he wanted to get rid of his last Magnum V4 drivers. In any case, Rhydon, upon learning of my situation, said in order to right the situation he'd be sending me a set of the new drivers on the house as soon as he had more made. What an upstanding guy Rhydon is!
So when that happens, we'll see if the new drivers have the same issue with sibilance or not. I don't know when that will be though.
Thanks for taking the time to try to diagnose this with me guys!