Sep 7, 2023 at 12:02 AM Post #5,913 of 6,408
Are you sure ?

Any examples ?

I have messed around a fair bit trying to figure out what files are what and I have not come across that situation.

I am not saying it doesn't exist but maybe it is a few outlier cases that are a result of their swapping over process being less than well implemented.
Yes
https://tidal.com/track/63483
 
Last edited:
Sep 7, 2023 at 4:26 AM Post #5,914 of 6,408
It's interesting how people argue about the bitrate. But if you cannot determine this quality by ear, then why are you interested in what quality of the stream you are provided with? placebo? :D
 
Sep 7, 2023 at 5:06 AM Post #5,916 of 6,408
It's interesting how people argue about the bitrate. But if you cannot determine this quality by ear, then why are you interested in what quality of the stream you are provided with? placebo? :D

Not placebo, just because it’s there.

You are right I doubt there are many people that could actually tell the difference I know I can’t. But if it is technically better why not, it looks good seeing a big number on a DAC screen right !! 😂
 
Sep 7, 2023 at 5:16 AM Post #5,917 of 6,408
I see that as MQA 44.1kHz. I have no way to tell what bit depth it is. Could it be 24 bit or can you see it is 16 ?

I know Qobuz call 24/44.1 Hi Res.

The original FLAC seems 16 bit (at least in ROON)

IMG_5842.jpeg


and also in UAPP

IMG_5843.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Sep 7, 2023 at 5:46 AM Post #5,919 of 6,408
I forgot about UAPP even though we are talking about Tidal and MQA in the UAPP forum !! 😂 Apparently we should not be doing that !!

Interesting, do Tidal consider anything MQA to be MAX quality ?

Yes, I apologize for fueling this OT discussion, but in reality this matter also concerns UAPP (as well as all the other alternative players),
in relation to its interfacing with TIDAL.

From what I understand updated API specifications need to be released to allow UAPP to interface with the new Hi-RES formats.
 
Sep 7, 2023 at 8:25 AM Post #5,920 of 6,408
Yes, I apologize for fueling this OT discussion, but in reality this matter also concerns UAPP (as well as all the other alternative players),
in relation to its interfacing with TIDAL.

From what I understand updated API specifications need to be released to allow UAPP to interface with the new Hi-RES formats.
Yes but in the meantime, Tidal should not be classifying these MQA 16/44 files as HiRes.
 
Sep 16, 2023 at 12:17 PM Post #5,923 of 6,408
Hi,
As the proud owner of UAPP I love to use it and would like to use it in a more consistent way.
But it is not really possible.
Because after a while music stops being playend and I get a message "Network Connection Lost".

I am using the UAPP latest version.
It runs on a Shanling M8 DAP.
It retrieves music from an Emby server from Wi-Fi network.
The Shanling player runs Android 7.1 version.
I have set UAPP to "not optimized" in Battery settings.

That "Network connection loss" does not happen with a "competitor" software... that is not as easy to use.

So if you got a hint about what is going on I'm a taker...
 
Sep 17, 2023 at 3:23 PM Post #5,924 of 6,408
It's interesting how people argue about the bitrate. But if you cannot determine this quality by ear, then why are you interested in what quality of the stream you are provided with? placebo? :D
Mostly the pretty lights I suspect. All joking aside, I'd be willing to bet barely anyone, if anyone, would be able to tell in a blind A/B. But that doesn't just apply to bitrate, it applies to pretty much everything "audiophile". In fairness, it is preferable to have the best quality where possible just for the sake of it as long as it isn't a big hassle to get.
 
Sep 17, 2023 at 3:25 PM Post #5,925 of 6,408
Hi,
As the proud owner of UAPP I love to use it and would like to use it in a more consistent way.
But it is not really possible.
Because after a while music stops being playend and I get a message "Network Connection Lost".

I am using the UAPP latest version.
It runs on a Shanling M8 DAP.
It retrieves music from an Emby server from Wi-Fi network.
The Shanling player runs Android 7.1 version.
I have set UAPP to "not optimized" in Battery settings.

That "Network connection loss" does not happen with a "competitor" software... that is not as easy to use.

So if you got a hint about what is going on I'm a taker...
I suspect Android 7.1 isn't helping your cause.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top