Pharmaboy
Headphoneus Supremus
Can't comment on the LCD-4z (haven't heard one), but I definitely have some thoughts about planar headphones co-existing w/dynamics.Quick question about staging i.e. specifically presentation on dynamic driver (Atrium) vs that of a relatively well-placed planar i.e. LCD4z for instance. Honestly I don't think the 4z has a particularly wide spacious sound stage comparatively when looking into the reviews. It does sound gorgeous (to my ears) but alas extremely intimate far as I can tell. I do not think I have ever really heard a headphone that has a truly wide and deep sound stage going by descriptions of this in many reviews. My current planar has just beautiful presentation, imminently listenable (I spend countless hours listening to it) but just really curious about how the Atrium would perform as a worthy stablemate to the venerable 4z. Since a prime attribute of the Atrium is the expansive sound stage, how would that compare to a planar driver in general, and the 4z planar in particular? Trying to imagine what such a wide and deep sound stage would be like referenced to my planars I have always owned (LCD1c, LCD2c, LCD3 pre-fazor, LCD-X, LCD4z, LCDi4) and never having listened to or owned a dynamic driver headphone. Obviously an actual audition to the new Atrium would be in order, but I have no way to do so.
From my first exposure to a planar headphone (ZMF Ori), I found them to sound significantly different from dynamics in certain ways:
- Well-done planar bass pleases me to no end. It seems more pressurized and heavier than dynamic bass
- Musical notes propagate differently from planar drivers: they just appear out of blackness, then disappear just as quickly. I've seen this described as inherently low driver distortion for planars...? Not sure, but I definitely hear it, particularly in the bass
- Dynamics often soundstage with greater space and depth, though some planars are exceptional in this way, too
- Dynamics vary quite a bit in their sound due to driver materials used (ie, biocellulose vs beryllium), while this is less of a factor w/planars
Right now my top dynamic is the ZMF Verite Open, with the new Atrium in close pursuit. They sound rather different & each is spectacular in its own way.
My first-love planar remains the ZMF Ori; it gives me the best bass I've heard from any headphone other than the big Abyss. Recently I've gone crazy for the Final D8000 w/the Pro's "G" earpads. I've owned a number of planars, including a couple LCDs, but the D8000 is the first one that delivers everything I could ask for: musicality; great bass; big, expressive mids; high resolution; slight warmth.