This is what I got:
Hi,
We now require the remaining balance for your purchase of the Realiser A16.
We will shortly send you a PayPal money request outlining how much you still need to pay.
Regards
James
Followed by paypal request (text is theirs, not mine):
Note to Smyth Research Ltd
Realiser A16 (Headstand) = $1690 Shipping = $ 70 Total = $1760 Less deposit = $700 Remaining amount to pay = $1060
Details
Sent to Smyth Research Ltd
$1,060.00 USD
Total
$1,060.00 USD
I got the same request, except now that I just went back through the initial contact, money requests and then the last part of the deposit, I was reminded of what my issue with this is.
Only on the initial $700 deposit does it mention that it's for the Realiser.
Pre-sale deposit for a Realiser A16 $700.00 USD (Qty)1 $700.00 USD
So it shows that I
partially paid for the Realiser.
The next contact was the same as in your post, but it has
a different transaction number from the initial $700. That might make sense for individual Paypal transactions, but it's still a separate transaction and doesn't actually prove that I paid the balance
for the same order.
Then, after paying the final $1,060, I get yet
a third transaction number that isn't connected in any way to the previous, and it also doesn't show that it was for the Realiser
anywhere. It just shows Smyth Research Ltd as the merchant, and then below it's simply blank and shows that I sent them $1,060 to them. That's it.
The sequence of events can be traced through the emails easily enough, but the way this was handled looks to give them a lot of legal wiggling room if they decided to go that route. With how utterly disorganized they've been with PR, I'm mainly worried about how they are filing these orders. I actually asked a few months after paying off the balance how they were doing that, and if there was a particular queue system they were using for the initial backers, and then last year's "June phase" of preorders, and they never gave me an answer. I asked primarily because of the update they gave later on about how it was unfortunate how they missed the deadline, and the units would be shipped out later, yet the "good news" is that once they started shipping them, everyone up through the June phase (but not September) would be getting theirs shipped out around the same time.
They then backpedalled on this yet again in a later update. Now it seems like the earliest adopters that Kickstarted will get theirs first (which they should), and all of the "preorders" are just up in the air at this point. On top of all of that, now they have to appease their partners. Who is keeping track of the orders now? I would hope that their bookkeeping department showed exactly how many units need to be shipped prior to being able to start selling them at $4,000 before any contracts were signed. But at this point I don't have a whole lot of faith in how they are handling it. I understand that Kickstarter can be messy, but I didn't Kickstart, I preordered after it was supposed to have been almost ready to ship.
In the event that this would need to be disputed, you only have 180 days with Paypal. After that, you're screwed. It's especially bad if you live in another country. I don't know when they cut off all new preorders, but even if it was December, they can still keep doing the whole "progress is coming along nicely...4-6 more weeks and we should start shipping!" until the end of this year and be in the clear if it never comes to fruition.