NEW - Campfire Comet and Atlas
Jun 10, 2018 at 3:54 PM Post #1,321 of 3,483
ok y’all here r my thoughts:

so I bought comets hated them sent them back thought they were missing something horribly in the midrange and then thanks to the amazing customer service from both JD and caleb they gave me a full refund provided that i was gonna upgrade to something like an orion or Polaris. I ended up getting the polaris, kept em for a week but the entire time wondering what the atlas would sound like. turns out campfire uses amazon pay and I just happened to have a $1500 credit limit on there. once again I call campfire asking ok can I send the polaris back and make the upgrade of all upgrades to the atlas. the customer service was legit as hell even sent me an RMA with free shipping back on the polaris. all I will say is that if you are even remotely into music and share the passion that we all do then it is 100% worth it to
get the atlas bc if u get something else you’ll just be like **** did I waste my money on inferior ****? the bass and sound is so nice, full bodied bass seriously like do what u can do get the atlas
Out of curiosity, what pushed you towards Atlas over Andromeda?
 
Jun 10, 2018 at 4:58 PM Post #1,323 of 3,483
ok y’all here r my thoughts:

so I bought comets hated them sent them back thought they were missing something horribly in the midrange and then thanks to the amazing customer service from both JD and caleb they gave me a full refund provided that i was gonna upgrade to something like an orion or Polaris. I ended up getting the polaris, kept em for a week but the entire time wondering what the atlas would sound like. turns out campfire uses amazon pay and I just happened to have a $1500 credit limit on there. once again I call campfire asking ok can I send the polaris back and make the upgrade of all upgrades to the atlas. the customer service was legit as hell even sent me an RMA with free shipping back on the polaris. all I will say is that if you are even remotely into music and share the passion that we all do then it is 100% worth it to
get the atlas bc if u get something else you’ll just be like **** did I waste my money on inferior ****? the bass and sound is so nice, full bodied bass seriously like do what u can do get the atlas

Good job. Sometimes its best to cry once, then forever have peace of mind knowing you have TOTL. At least until the new one comes out...
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 5:54 AM Post #1,325 of 3,483
Anyone compared the Audio 64 tia fourte against the Campfire Atlas?can't believe the price of the Audio 64

Never heard the Tia Fourte, but from what I heard people say and other review, it is different sounding as the Atlas is certainly has strong bass.
Seems like The Fourte is closer to the Andromeda but with nicer overall bass rendition among other technical improvements.

Since The Atlas is basically a super Vega, you may find this comparison interesting, as is done by Twister6

"Fourte vs Vega - Fourte has a wider soundstage while Vega has more depth; both have a similar quality of sub-bass rumble, while the quantity is more elevated in Vega, and the same with mid-bass which is a little faster in Vega - it has more impact with a stronger punch. Lower mids in Vega have a little more body, while upper mids are pushed a little back in comparison to a brighter, more revealing, more transparent, and more forward mids of Fourte. Fourte treble is crisper and has more airiness. These have a noticeably different signature with Fourte being a little more mid-forward while in relative comparison Vega is more L-shaped."

Like you said, it is really expensive, I would never spend that kind of money on a set of IEMs, diminishing returns hits extremely hard at this level and I prefer to spend big on desktop setup with desktop amp/dac, or maybe invest my money elsewhere.

The Atlas itself is already expensive, however it looks like a great deal compared to the Tia Fourte or even to the Legend X.
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 6:10 AM Post #1,327 of 3,483
Never heard the Tia Fourte, but from what I heard people say and other review, it is different sounding as the Atlas is certainly has strong bass.
Seems like The Fourte is closer to the Andromeda but with nicer overall bass rendition among other technical improvements.

Since The Atlas is basically a super Vega, you may find this comparison interesting, as is done by Twister6

"Fourte vs Vega - Fourte has a wider soundstage while Vega has more depth; both have a similar quality of sub-bass rumble, while the quantity is more elevated in Vega, and the same with mid-bass which is a little faster in Vega - it has more impact with a stronger punch. Lower mids in Vega have a little more body, while upper mids are pushed a little back in comparison to a brighter, more revealing, more transparent, and more forward mids of Fourte. Fourte treble is crisper and has more airiness. These have a noticeably different signature with Fourte being a little more mid-forward while in relative comparison Vega is more L-shaped."

Like you said, it is really expensive, I would never spend that kind of money on a set of IEMs, diminishing returns hits extremely hard at this level and I prefer to spend big on desktop setup with desktop amp/dac, or maybe invest my money elsewhere.

The Atlas itself is already expensive, however it looks like a great deal compared to the Tia Fourte or even to the Legend X.
I'm gonna spend money on a better dac as I've traded in my hugo 2 for the hugo TT 2 but like you say the more you spend at this level the less the jump in improvement, I would spend over 3 grand on i.e.ms as I'm not going down the route of over head headphones so I want state of the art, the best I can stretch to afford but the comparison with the Vega is interesting and with the Atlas being better again I don't know if the Audio 64 would be an improvement
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 6:46 AM Post #1,328 of 3,483
I'm gonna spend money on a better dac as I've traded in my hugo 2 for the hugo TT 2 but like you say the more you spend at this level the less the jump in improvement, I would spend over 3 grand on i.e.ms as I'm not going down the route of over head headphones so I want state of the art, the best I can stretch to afford but the comparison with the Vega is interesting and with the Atlas being better again I don't know if the Audio 64 would be an improvement

You meant you traded your TT with Hugo 2 right? I thought The TT is bigger.
Understandable, I also had thought of going portable summit-fi instead of the full desktop one, but decided against it for now, but sometimes life get busy and it is just easier to enjoy the music using portable gears (DAP -> IEM quick and easy).

I think the most important thing is the tonality, if that doesn't fit in, everything else will not work albeit being technically excellent.

The Tia Fourte is so much money though, I was interested in that too along with the EE Legend X, but both not available for demo in Australian audio stores, I just cant go all in with that kind of money without trying it on for an extended amount of time.
I've also made a commitment to not spend over 2k on audio gears.

Good luck on the hunt man! hehe
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 6:52 AM Post #1,329 of 3,483
You meant you traded your TT with Hugo 2 right? I thought The TT is bigger.
Understandable, I also had thought of going portable summit-fi instead of the full desktop one, but decided against it for now, but sometimes life get busy and it is just easier to enjoy the music using portable gears (DAP -> IEM quick and easy).

I think the most important thing is the tonality, if that doesn't fit in, everything else will not work albeit being technically excellent.

The Tia Fourte is so much money though, I was interested in that too along with the EE Legend X, but both not available for demo in Australian audio stores, I just cant go all in with that kind of money without trying it on for an extended amount of time.
I've also made a commitment to not spend over 2k on audio gears.

Good luck on the hunt man! hehe
Oh I have been on the same boat as well. Was really curious about legend X and Tia forte. As you said it's not available for demo with Australian retailers and also if you covert it to AUD, it's way too much money to spend on an iem.
 
Last edited:
Jun 11, 2018 at 7:15 AM Post #1,330 of 3,483
Oh I have been on the same boat as well. Was really curious about legend X and Tia forte. As you said it's not available for demo with Australian retailers and also if you covert it to AUD, it's way too much money to spend on an iem.

I know right! So much money there, and without guerentee!
To make it worse, it is also difficult to sell it on if you don't like it! It seems that there are not that many of us here in Australia, nobody is interested in audio gear!
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 7:28 AM Post #1,331 of 3,483
You meant you traded your TT with Hugo 2 right? I thought The TT is bigger.
Understandable, I also had thought of going portable summit-fi instead of the full desktop one, but decided against it for now, but sometimes life get busy and it is just easier to enjoy the music using portable gears (DAP -> IEM quick and easy).

I think the most important thing is the tonality, if that doesn't fit in, everything else will not work albeit being technically excellent.

The Tia Fourte is so much money though, I was interested in that too along with the EE Legend X, but both not available for demo in Australian audio stores, I just cant go all in with that kind of money without trying it on for an extended amount of time.
I've also made a commitment to not spend over 2k on audio gears.

Good luck on the hunt man! hehe
No mate I meant I traded in my hugo 2 for the hugo TT 2 but got it on pre order,this might seem insane but I don't want portable anymore I want desk top but I want the portable i.e.ms but will only listen to them in the comfort of my lounge, this is why I don't know why extension cables of high quality aren't available for i.e.m's,qed do one but it's hardly high quality compared to the Atlas cable.I.e.m's use to be for convenience but that's not the case anymore
 
Last edited:
Jun 11, 2018 at 7:29 AM Post #1,332 of 3,483
I know right! So much money there, and without guerentee!
To make it worse, it is also difficult to sell it on if you don't like it! It seems that there are not that many of us here in Australia, nobody is interested in audio gear!
Yeah I dont see much value for resale as well in Australia. I guess most people are happy with the likes of beats.
I was waiting for release of another iem and accidentally came across this thread. I haven't bought any campfire products before mostly because of the pricing in Australia. I came across comets and was really curious. Placed An order without demoing them because you generally don't find them for demo.
But I have to say am really happy with comets now. But would yes I might end up trying out atlas soon.
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 7:32 AM Post #1,333 of 3,483
Jun 11, 2018 at 7:50 AM Post #1,334 of 3,483
Quite different cables.

I covered them in my review.
(In the Head-fi review section or via my sig).

But I am updating the review soon as I removed the memory wire on the SXC-8 and am checking the new fit.

Oooo mann, I need that silver stock cable in 2.5mm.
I've contacted CA from their website and see what they can do with it, It would be good if we are able to change the termination at purchase.
 
Jun 11, 2018 at 12:14 PM Post #1,335 of 3,483
I've really been enjoying Currawong reviews on kit I'm thinking of getting, I thought he was Chinese or Japanese before I read the reviews, Sony Z1R and the campfire audio Atlas really good reviews
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top