My $200-$300 Full Sized Can Shootout - Q701, HD598, K550
Sep 11, 2012 at 7:40 PM Thread Starter Post #1 of 5

orbilius

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Posts
116
Likes
261
I wanted to share some quick impressions on my search for a new full sized headphone.  Practicality and portability are important to me.  I travel often and they need to be durable and able to be powered off of a portable amp and the occasional laptop/iphone/sansa.  I am in NYC this week for work and decided to buy several contenders to see which one best matched my preferences.  
 
I used to use Denon D2000s.  Loved them across all genres, but traveling with them tended to break the attachment of the driver to the band.  After two warranty replacements I sold them.  I use Shure 315 IEMs for workouts/airplanes and enjoy their signature.  My temporary full size headphone has been the Superlux HD681.  I use the full size headphones at home and in hotels for music and movies.  The Superlux is a fantastic performer for the money, but I was missing the quality of the Denon.
 
The contenders:
 
AKG Q701 - I know this is a very different signature than the Denon, but I was always curious about the K701.
AKG K550 - I only became familiar with these this week and read most of the threads here.  
Sennheiser HD 598   - I had some 598s way back in the day before owning some Koss ESP 950s.  Haven't been exposed to the Senn sound for some time.  
 
I wanted to keep the budget under $300.
 
System:  Macbook Air - FLAC - USB - FIIO E17
 
Musical Preferences - Folk Rock, Jazz, Classical, Modern Rock, Live Concert Recordings. 
 
Observations:
  1. Q701 - loved the feel of the headphone.  Super comfortable.  Nice build quality.  Initial good impressions, but I kept turning the volume down with songs with higher frequency content.  I was missing the body of the Denons on tunes with good bass lines. As much as I wanted to like them they just didn't engage me.  Most likely under amped by the E17, but unwilling to invest more in a higher powered amp.  I actually found the Superlux more engaging after trimming the high frequencies a bit.  
  2. Senn 598 - Looked like a grandma's Lincoln Town Car with the beige and fake wood.  Warm, dynamic, but lacking enough detail  for my taste.  I didn't listen long.  My initial impression was pretty strong.  
  3. K550 - First, the build is fantastic.  Metal>Plastic.  The folding cups is a killer feature for me.  I can fit them in my small travel bag with the Macbook Air and have great sound in a small package.  Sound - more body, enough detail.  Dynamics that sound like music.  Obviously less flat and reference than the 701s, but I enjoyed the tunes I was listening to across genres.  Also, they don't need the E17 to sound decent.  Respectable results from portable sources and straight out of the mac.  Ears get a bit hot from the sealed pleather cups.  
 
I think the K550 is my headphone for practical and sound quality reasons.  
 
Sep 11, 2012 at 7:44 PM Post #2 of 5
K701? i thought you had the "Q" version. (from what i know there's a slight difference between them?)
 
But thanks for the quick comparison, i fell in love with my K550 from the first day. They are great for classical and orchestras. 
 
Sep 11, 2012 at 8:36 PM Post #4 of 5
Heya,
 
On your quest, if you choose to continue, here's some suggestions to also attempt to try (maybe buy from places that allow returns):
 
Brainwavz HM5 (Fischer Audio FA003)
Fischer Audio FA-002
AudioTechnica A900X
Ultrasone PRO 750
Ultrasone HFI 2400
Shure SRH840
Beyer DT770
Beyer DT880
Hifiman HE-300 revision 2
Fostex T50RP (modded; Mad Dogs or Paradox)
 
My portable of choice is a premium Beyer DT770, with black velour pads, and aftermarket re-cabled to have a detachable locking cable that is 4 feet long and sleeved, terminating to 3.5mm with an extension of the same cabling for home use. Tank like. Big. Comfortable. Great sound.
 
Very best,
 
Sep 11, 2012 at 9:44 PM Post #5 of 5
Yes it would be nice to have some ultrasones compared against others. Nice job. 
smile.gif

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top