Thinking about these button placements a bit more I don’t feel they’re very intuitive. Of course it’s subjective but I’ll give my reasons why and I’m curious if people agree would with this. Sorry if I’m boring people with this subject but I find things like this interesting and I’ll shut up about it after this if no one cares
Anyway…
The only reason to have the skip forward button facing downwards is to follow the direction of the track list visually, top to bottom. But I have 3 good reasons why skip forward should be facing upwards.
- This is always the direction of the volume on literally every device with a side volume control. Up is + and down is - so it’s reasonable to think the track skip direction should be the same. This is how Sony does it and I don’t see a good reason to go the other direction.
- When using the device while looking at the screen I’m more inclined to use the touch screen to change tracks, not the physical buttons. The buttons are there mainly if i want to use the device blind, like laying in bed at night or when in your pocket etc. This is the main reason I use a dap in the first place, for blind operation with physical buttons. Usually if I use the buttons while looking at the screen it’s to change tracks or volume while doing something in another menu where the change track buttons aren’t displayed on screen.
- Another small reason might be good for when the volume wheel is placed on top of the device like the R6 III. When you skip to the next track the first thing people might do is adjust the volume for a specific track as needed. Like playing random tracks the very next track might be very loud compared to the previous track. So if the skip forward was a couple of buttons closer to the volume wheel it would be less movement to make when using the device single handed. Just slightly easier.
Not really part of it but also relative to the discussion is the positioning of the volume buttons. I feel they should be on the left side of the device if you’re right handed, which is who most things are designed for right handed people.
- If using the device while looking at the screen it will be held in my left hand because I use my right hand to navigate the touch screen. On most music apps the main central control in the middle of the screen is for the skip/pause tracks. The volume is usually somewhere further away on the screen (depending on what app you’re using of course). So it makes sense to have the volume buttons on the left side because your left hand thumb is already resting in that exact spot, the left side of the device. So you have easier access to both track skip and volume simultaneously as opposed to easier access to two lots of skip track and play/pause. This is where volume is located on most phones for a similar reason. It’s there so righties can access the volume easily while holding the device normally. And it can be important to have quick access to the volume as you could be at risk of a sudden loud noise from the next track that could damage your hearing.
- Then on the other side of things (pun intended) if I’m using the player sitting beside me on a couch or in bed etc, (like when I want to navigate single handed) then it will be held in my right hand. The device would be laying flat with screen facing up with my hand over the top of the device, and using my right thumb as the volume control and index finger for track skip/play/pause. Not sure if this is common but I just feel like my thumb is the best suited for volume control for no particular reason other than it just feels more correct.
I’m not sure if any daps have this exact layout but I feel this would be perfect and the most intuitive, for me at least haha.