saxelrod92, how the LCD-2 compared vs the Alpha Prime in terms of detail retrieval, resolution, soundstage, bass, mids (is more forward, recessed), etc.
Which is better in these areas?. Which have better bass quality, mids and treble?
Thanks in advance for the comparison
I can only say in regards to the lcd-2 I have, which is from 2013 without the fazor, so please take that into consideration first. Otherwise let me get to it
So in general the alpha prime is definitely the more detailed, higher resolution, larger soundstage (and better imaging), tighter stronger bass thats just as deep and textured, mids go to the lcd-2 because they are slightly more forward and the primes are a bit further back but still very well balanced, highs depend on how sensitive you are to a hard edge in the sound and the gear you use. The primes are really transparent so they will sound like the gear you use to en extent, and without adding the tuning dots, they can with some sounds get a bit edgy but still very smooth overall (for the music I listen to I actually like the edge because its just enough to give music a solid feel, and it's not in any way too edgy or sibilant). but again the lcd-2 is going to be smoother overall, and be way less sensitive to the highs, I sometimes consider them the anti-sibilance headphones because its just nearly impossible to hear sibilance with them lol. The primes are dead neutral, but retain a fuller dynamic sound like the lcd-2. They're actually not that different from each other, just that the primes are much more neutral and have more detail, and a better soundstage and imaging.
Comfort is going to be a deciding factor here too though. the lcd-2 might be heavier, and have a more uncomfortable headband, but they have the large ear pads, and as such have a more comfortable feel around the ear, if you dont mind the weight and top of the head pressure. The primes are lighter, and have a great suspension strap system to relive all head pressure, but they have a higher clamp force because they are very sensitive to getting a good seal. Also the ear cups cant tilt up and down much, so if you are like me and most headphones tend to be more in a V shape when on your head, then the primes will put more pressure at the top of your ear area. You can reduce this by reducing the clamp and rotating the pads back, so there's options.
Also another big one is isolation. the lcd-2 is an open headphone and as such you will obviously hear all the sounds in your room, and people around you will hear what you are listening to. The primes are closed back and actually isolate very well. So they have a blacker background from this, and they can be a bit more dynamic sounding as a result.
The primes definitely win hands down with the bass. its simply more powerful, harder hitting, and just textured and detailed and goes just as low, its perfect bass in my opinion, and it securely stays within its frequency spectrum. The mids will go to the lcd-2 because its hard to beat up close, sweet sounding mids (the primes have mids that sound right, but dont stand out like they do on the lcd-2), and the treble for me goes to the primes, because my pair of lcd-2s pre-fazor just are too dulled in that area and it becomes very obvious they are simply not even playing certain details and sounds up there that are supposed to be there. But if you are super sensitive to sibilance, hardness, edge, and just want something laid back and sweet for the treble, then the lcd-2 wins.
I wish I have heard the fazor version so I can compare bass better, because on my lcd-2 the bass is just straight up weak, its full and textured, but its annoyingly weak. It cant hold down the low frequency spectrum properly, the other frequencies over-power the bass on my lcd-2. and the soft, laid-back nature of them makes the bass lose most of its attack, which is what help you hear bass within a song. But supposedly the fazor fixes this issue quite a bit, so that version could be closer to the primes. But I think regardless of that primes will have more detail, resolution, isolation, and neutrality, while still sounding full and dynamic.
I think its just a matter of what feels more comfortable to wear for you at the end of the day, because either headphone (assuming the lcd-2 is fazor) should sound exactly like a 1000 dollar headphone should. different heads different comfort. I'm still undecided on whether to keep the primes or not because of comfort. Still just messing around with adjustments. The lcd-2 you get used to eventually, but the weight is always noticeable.
Let me know if theres a specific comparison between these two you want more detail on, and I hope this helps!