re. the recent Beethoven cycle discussion, I just heard a remarkable new(ish) recording of the Beethoven 5&7th symphonies by the Pittsburgh Symphony conducted by Manfred Honeck on Reference Recordings. When I first saw this recording, my reaction was the usual, "Who needs another Beethoven 5&7?" especially from an audiophile label. As it turns out, and I say this as a Carlos Kleiber fanboy, this is the most exciting, interesting recording of the 5th I've heard, and totally eclipses the Kleiber for me. The sound is pretty good too, and it comes as a multichannel SACD if you're into that. The CD layer is also HDCD encoded if you're into that. It has a slightly leaner, more precise version of the RR house sound: lots of warm reverb, but less than the Keith Johnson recordings, with things more naturally placed in their acoustic, and less extreme dynamics.
Never mind all of that stuff, because the qualities of this recording are audible even over FM radio, which is where I heard it first, and it made me sit in my car parked until it finished. The range of expression --- tempi and dynamics --- is wide and more importantly intelligently used. There are some historically-informed performances where you always feel like they're just showing off their crazy effects with little to negative benefit for the music. Not so here: Honeck (who apparently has extensively studied the music from historical sources) makes it sound like the most exciting, dramatic, and epic music. It's the 5th symphony you'd air conduct in your head, except it's real!
Just a couple of examples: the opening of the first movement starts with 4 slow, angry knocks, and then is contrasted against the faster response, so it sounds like there's an Olympian conversation going on. The opening of the 4th movement actually makes the orchestra sounds like it's growling. I have no idea how he does that, but it's very exciting, and there are all sorts of details I just don't hear in other recordings.
Check it out: it will be worth your time!