Apr 24, 2021 at 12:46 PM Post #4,775 of 6,452
Hello, any chance to disable the 1st software MQA unfolding on the UAPP?
My iDSD Diablo works as a renderer only with UAPP but it can make a full hardware decoding. Thanks.

Unfortunately UAPP doesn't have a setting to disable the software decoder, at least not to my knowledge.

UAPP sends a USB HID command to the DAC to query its MQA support, and uses that to determine whether to perform first unfold. This works perfectly on my MQA USB DAC as well as another non-MQA I had for a while. But it would appear that the iDSD doesn't respond correctly to this query.

I would write to the Dev (use the About screen). It is possible that he can simply add the iDSD to his list of known DACs.

That said, I think there SHOULD be a setting to manually disable the software decoder.
 
Apr 24, 2021 at 12:58 PM Post #4,776 of 6,452
Unfortunately UAPP doesn't have a setting to disable the software decoder, at least not to my knowledge.

UAPP sends a USB HID command to the DAC to query its MQA support, and uses that to determine whether to perform first unfold. This works perfectly on my MQA USB DAC as well as another non-MQA I had for a while. But it would appear that the iDSD doesn't respond correctly to this query.

I would write to the Dev (use the About screen). It is possible that he can simply add the iDSD to his list of known DACs.

That said, I think there SHOULD be a setting to manually disable the software decoder.

MQA is at fault for the option not existing...

https://www.extreamsd.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=853

F296EF80-BC49-4010-ACBA-1FD18533F2CE.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Apr 24, 2021 at 1:12 PM Post #4,777 of 6,452
"Thank you for contacting us. That is what should automatically happen since UAPP should detect if a USB DAC is a MQA decoder."
So it is not happening with Diablo...
P.S. The source (digital transport for Diablo) is sony nw-a105 DAP on Android 9.
 
Last edited:
Apr 24, 2021 at 1:33 PM Post #4,779 of 6,452
"Thank you for contacting us. That is what should automatically happen since UAPP should detect if a USB DAC is a MQA decoder."
So it is not happening with Diablo...
P.S. The source (digital transport for Diablo) is sony nw-a105 DAP on Android 9.

I agree, it should happen automatically, but what when it doesn't? He didn't have an answer to that? Be nice to have a technical request to forward to iDSD.
 
Last edited:
Apr 24, 2021 at 1:42 PM Post #4,780 of 6,452
I too have repeatedly complained about the millions of 16/44 Masters on Tidal (mostly from Warner) which do not contain any origami and thus do not represent any improved SQ. But those who strive to avoid MQA should have no problem with those tracks.

Based on what you’ve observed, do you think the Warner and other 16/44 Master files would sound them same whether played with or without MQA output enabled since there is no unfolding going on? That’s one of my takeaways from what you’ve shared, just checking if that’s the case if you might know.
 
Last edited:
Apr 24, 2021 at 1:45 PM Post #4,781 of 6,452
I agree, it should happen automatically, but what when it doesn't? He didn't have an answer to that? Be nice to have a technical request to forward to iDSD.
Yeah, I asked ifi audio. We'll see.
 
Apr 24, 2021 at 2:12 PM Post #4,782 of 6,452
Based on what you’ve observed, do you think the Warner and other 16/44 Master files would sound them same whether played with or without MQA output enabled since there is no unfolding going on? That’s one of my takeaways from what you’ve shared, just checking if that’s the case if you might know.

Since my original complaints about these, I've performed some comparisons to CDs I own of the same albums. And there were definitely differences, both audibly and in the actual files. I am happy to share a bit more, just not today. And I think it is safer and more appropriate for the Tidal Masters & MQA Thread.
 
Apr 24, 2021 at 2:35 PM Post #4,783 of 6,452
Since my original complaints about these, I've performed some comparisons to CDs I own of the same albums. And there were definitely differences, both audibly and in the actual files. I am happy to share a bit more, just not today. And I think it is safer and more appropriate for the Tidal Masters & MQA Thread.

Cool - I will hop over there. I guess my question was unclear, I’m not doubting the files have been modified, I’m just wondering if an mqa decoder or renderer would change the playback sound of the file.
 
Apr 24, 2021 at 2:43 PM Post #4,784 of 6,452
Cool - I will hop over there. I guess my question was unclear, I’m not doubting the files have been modified, I’m just wondering if an mqa decoder or renderer would change the playback sound of the file.

Your question was clear enough, and I'll post my thoughts on it over there. Hopefully later this week.
 
Apr 24, 2021 at 4:19 PM Post #4,785 of 6,452
For those who have been around awhile. Some of you might remember that its been years that I use an Android Box (now a Beelink GT-King) as streamer/network player thru a NAS on my system. With addtional LPS, USB Regen/Reclock and now a DDC (Singxer SU-6) as additions.

Never had explored remote controlling the Android Box since I don't need it. Maybe on a loudspeaker setup but not on headphones in my home work station/desktop.

Well had a little test tonight and say it works using TEAMVIEWER. My smartphone as remote controller and Andoid Box as Host. On this pic it is playing an SACD-ISO on a NAS.

Just to let you know. Or I am already late to the party....

20210424_220324.jpg
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top