So --- audio listening preferences (music, equipment, basshead, treblehead, etc.) are personal...no right or wrong here! Whatever floats your boat, good on you.
TBH, the idea that someone would/should change their own preference to align with another's (i.e. Speakers vs IEMs, 'fidelity' to the artist's/engineer's intent vs 'infidelity' , etc.) simply because they haven't truly experienced the pinnacle of the 'best' acoustic delivery mode (argued earlier in the thread) is honestly insulting. 'Really...you just don't know any better...poor schlep' Ugh! That thinking is behind so much of what is wrong with the world today.
Anecdotally, regarding the market's preference for Speakers vs IEMs / Headphones, I really feel like there's been a major shift.
My kids (Millennials) don't even own a stereo system or a home theater but they do own earbuds, tws iems and headphones. Same goes for the majority of their friends. They listen to music from their phones, watch movies on their laptops, and when they do watch content on their TVs...they're happy with the speakers in the TV. I actually have a nice 5.1 HT system that I tried to give to my son a few years ago when I upgraded. He turned it down -- didn't see the need for it!
And their kids?...are using iems or gaming headphones on their Xbox or Nintendo Switch while they're playing Fortnite, Minecraft, etc.
Would be curious to hear what the next generations in your 'circle' are using to enjoy music and movies...
Ah, they are not my circle. I actually want very high quality sound! I'm a retired software engineer with plenty of money to spend on this hobby.
I have a completely unsubstantiated theory as to why I like IEMs more than any speaker system I heard. I also think its a reason why speaker people are generally older (although the highest market sales right now, in billions, are soundbar speakers).
Do you remember the first time you tasted hard liqueur (not sweet)? Godawful wasn't it? But then the pleasure that became associated with it! In short order, if so inclined, you become a connoisseur and the taste becomes sublime. If it was Rum, you like Rum, if Scotch then only that will do.
What was your first experience with music from a device (speaker, headphone, IEM)? Usually it was on some cheap piece of trash if you were young. Mine personally was monaural radio, then Koss headphones, 5.1 surround sound speakers for the TV, and finally Bose headphones 10 years ago. Each step was an improvement. 5 years ago I got my first Etymotic IEM. What a revelation! What pleasure! The psychological anchor was set.
Since then I thought I would get more satisfaction from a good speaker system (because lots of folks said so) and hunted for them in high end music stores to no avail. I listened for hours to my friends very expensive system. Sorry, I just want my IEM. I wanted speakers that would reproduce that pleasure, but failed. I proceeded to buy ever more expensive IEMs which separated me ever further from speaker systems, that for me, were decidedly inferior. I bought headphones which are nice when you get tired of having a plunger in your ear.
The point is, I think everyone is subject to this psychological anchoring bias. If your first significant pleasure was with a good speaker system you are now biased, for ever more, to those sound cues. You will never be satisfied with headphones or IEMs. It will always be perceived as a step down.
But one should not think there is any scientific validity to these biases in the physical world. They are only valid in the biggest DSP in the chain, your brain. I look forward to when we can have better measurements, not only for FR, noise, and distortion, but for detail, sound-stage, and imaging. At a certain point we will be able to look at a spec and truly choose what we prefer without having to try everything under the sun, which is difficult and often impractical.
Last edited: