Quote:
That is very cool stuff. I have never seen a headphone with a polarity switch. Cool stuff.
You mentioned that material has little to do with it, I am curious though. The RS1 and Magnum in wood have similar signatures, I wonder if you put one of those drivers in metal (either or both) how much it would change. The consistency there makes me wonder if some of it isn't the wood.
It's true that this is a wooden jacket Magnum, and the RS1 is also wood, but I don't believe that, metal or wood, would change the sound signature itself. Those materials will add certain attributes to the sound, a new vibe on their own, but not alter the sound signature of a driver. They have results akin to when you tune a T50RP mod. Balance of a driver will also remain roughly the same, if all you do is change the material. This is more true for open headphones at least.
Metal >> Plastic though... I have a SR100 (ABS plastic), a SR325 (ABS plastic metal hybrid), and a HP2 (full metal), all with the HP-1000 drivers in them, and the difference is very real, SR100 < SR325 < HP2. It's hard to describe but metal, or aluminum alloy in this case, is harder, less resonant, and gives better output, somehow. The driver will sound louder and seems more detailed to me (because less "low-level" energy is lost, I imagine. Sorry if I'm not precise at all, lol).
The consistency in the graphs I've posted are not due to the wood, far from it
. They are due to the Grado driver,s which all have the same morphology (but sometimes with a reflex dot on the back of the magnet plate), but only a different grade and a different fine-tuning/doping. I shown you the www.headphone.com graph, SR60 vs SR325 vs RS1 vs PS500 to show you how similar they were together.
SR60, SR325, RS1, PS500
(www.headphone.com)
Those are all similar curves
But definitely the PS500 is the first ambassador of Grado's new sound... less shrill highs and darker, and it's popular because of that. The frequency response curve has been skewed by 5-10 degrees anti-clockwise, but the arrangement of the peaks and their relative height is still very much the same. I think that the PS500 is like this because of a new driver formula, and not so much the enclosure... but I could be wrong. Also I don't understand what makes the GS1000i and PS-1000 big mushroom cups sounding so different than the medium turbines.
Btw, Rhythmdevils is one to think the HP-1000 is better than the Magnum:
http://www.head-fi.org/t/596028/joe-grado-hp1000-modifications/30#post_8214831