The D1/HDAM listening session continues with the Sun HDAM (audio-gd):
The Sun is definitely tilted toward the top. I'd say it's up 6 dB from 6K Hz up. Very tilted. Listening to Chicago (Sufjan Stephens), our "reference song" for this comparison (me and my 8 year old son, Aidan), the ethereal voices really shimmer. Unlike with the Earth HDAM, Sufjan doesn't groove as much, but still sounds "right." The Earth really "boogies," where the Sun puts the spotlight on voices and cymbals. Love the cymbals with earth; pristine; crystaline. About the best top-end rendition I can remember hearing. Now, listening to Adrian Belew, "Here," confirming that pristine top end.
I don't want to suggest that the Sun is lacking at the bottom, now listening to Stars, "Genova Heights," shows that the Sun can clearly "boogie" too. The bass line really comes across here.
What surprises me is just how much I am enjoying the rendition of high frequency material. I expected the Sun to be just plain "bright," so I originally ordered only the Moon HDAM's. I am glad I later went in for the Earth and Sun. The Sun makes it a treat to listen to anything with well-recorded top end. There is a golden quality to vocals and acoustic guitar that is quite special. Susan Mckeown sounds splendid, BTW on this setup.
If you don't have Molina and Johnson (the collaboration between bandleaders of Magnolia Electric Company and Centro-Matic), I could listen to it over and over on the D1 with the Sun HDAM. Wow. Warmth with articulation and detail in spades. Guitar solos (sounds like they recorded them with a ribbon mic
, are honey sweet. Vocals are amazing; pure, rich and caramelly. The winsome, somewhat dark quality of this mostly acoustic album comes through.
D1 with Sun HDAM was made for Death Cab For Cutie. Transatlanticism is more present and affecting than I have ever heard it.
Iron and Wine, Shepherds Dog: Percussion is superb with the Sun. Transients are thrilling. Bass seems very well rendered. You could be a conoissiuer of reverb with the Sun in the D1.
Abigail Washburn, Songs of the Traveling Daughter. I actually enjoy the vocal renditions on this album for the first time. This is very spare, well recorded female vocal music and banjo, and it is crisp, but warmer than I expected to find it with the Sun.
Sufjan Stevens, Michigan: This is darker than I expected to find it with the Sun. Very pleasingly ultra-crisp, but somehow "dark" at the same time. Ultra-articulated, but very smooth. Vocal sibilance is actually enjoyable with this combination.
My summary comment at this point is that I am having a blast rolling discrete op amps. I really, really like the Moon HDAM, but as of today, I can say that I am really glad I bought the others, and that I can roll op amps like I roll tubes. Also, I am falling in love with transistors (OK, at least appreciating them deeply) in a way I did not expect to. In a well designed circuit, as my friend Rupert Neve often harps about, they can be superb. OK, count me a believer.
Background: I tried all the listed, IC op amp combinations in the DAC and Headphone positions that were recommended in the FAQ for the D1. So far, I am enjoying the HDAM's a lot more. That said, if I had to go back to an IC op amp, I seem to prefer the stock units. I already went back to the stock op amp for the headphone output, as the only HDAM I tried there didn't work at all (just popping and almost inaudible audio, using the Moon HDAM).
Issues that remain: all these HDAM's clip at high volume. I think the D1 doesn't supply an optimal voltage for the operating characteristics of the HDAM's from audio-gd. I know this sounds horribly compromised, and like a non-starter as an option in the D1, but darn these sound good at normal+ listening levels! Know that I am a shameless audio snob. Anything but single-ended, class A (generally with triodes) is palid and unappealing to me most of the time. That said, I am loving what I hear.
Listening to amazing Celtic Violin right now (Hayes and Cahill, The Lonesome Touch), and this is making for the beginnings of a splendid day off!
Let the listening continue! Back to HDAM rolling!
Marc
My Setup: Airport Express Digital Out > Maverick D1 (WE 396a) > DIY Transformer Coupled 300B SE Amp > DIY Alpair 10 Speakers in MarKen10 Cabinets. Power: 110 VAC (Pure Sin Wave) via Texas Sunshine > Unisolar and Kyocera Panels > Outback Charger Controllers and Inverters > Nickel Iron Batteries