Jazzwave,
Sizzlincock is absolutely correct, that thread has a ton of information available on tube and opamp rolling. My only issue is that there are nearly 2600 posts to sift through, and some of the replies are in regards to older equipment which may not now be rolling off of the assembly line now. The standard upgrade tube that Maverick is supplying in the D1 and D2 is a 1970s GE black plate "O" getter. It is an excellent all around tube with no major flaws, it does everything well across the board and most people will not feel the need to upgrade this tube.
I am not that person, and I have tried many tubes in my D2.....most of which I tried and later sold back on eBay, the ones I've kept are:
(First place tie) Made in New Jersey Bendix 2C51 (1960s) or 6385 (1950s) - Both tubes involved me in the music and delivered terrific bass, and class leading all around performance in my system and great sound stage. The 1950s 6385 is clearly the best of the two (and would be my "cost no object" tube), but at $150 to $400 PER TUBE cost is an object for me....I loved it and sold it. It delivers what other tubes in this class do not, deep/defined/detailed bass. The 2C51 has most of the terrific traits of the 6385, but loses the magic of the bass and seems to have a slight "hole" in the midrange as well. The 6385 is the best tube available in this line, but is insanely expensive. The 2C51 is a hair below or equivalent to the Sylvania, and at $40 to $80 per tube is in the reach of many of us.
(First place tie) Sylvania Gold Series GB5670 or 5670WA (both early 1960s) - Better or equal to the GE in most respects, more punchy and defined bass without becoming "muddy", highs are very detailed but not annoying.....not able to pinpoint why, but got me much more involved in the music. Cost $25 to $40 per tube, and a bargain at that price.
(First place tie) Western Electric WE396A 1950s vinatage - I tried two of these tubes, one from the early 1950s and one from the late 1950s. Both were incredible when they were "on" even pushing the Bendix 6385, but are "finicky" in that they do not sound the same on all source material. I am not sure if that is a flaw in the musicality, or if it is more related to the fact that they can be noisy and are not "black" in the background. NOTE: I still own the tubes and will spend more time in the future trying to figure that issue out.
Hope that gives some help from another review.