HifiMAN HE-6 Planar Magnetic Headphone
Feb 27, 2016 at 9:31 PM Post #18,376 of 21,867
 
Thanks for posting those measurements.
I'm guessing that it may be the bigger dip at 2khz for the Focus pads that I dislike - just creating too much suck-out in the mids relative to treble and response below 1khz.
This might also explain my preference for the HD600 over HE6/Focus pads. HD600 doesn't dip much at all at this frequency - hence gives a more forward sound than even the HE6/stock velour combo, though at the expense of some perspective.
I kind of expected to see the treble energy of the Focus pads more attenuated in comparison to the velour.
The Audeze pads 'look' interesting as they pretty much flatten out after 2KHz which might correlate with a smooth balance. Would be interesting to see the response of these pads with the grill mod.
 
Edit: what the hell, just rolled the dice and ordered some vegan pads

Dip in the 2khz = less forward sound?  This is the first time I've heard this.
 
Feb 27, 2016 at 10:20 PM Post #18,377 of 21,867
  Dip in the 2khz = less forward sound?  This is the first time I've heard this.

 
If you compared the HD600 to the HE6 you would know exactly what I mean.
The HD600 provides more robust, mid centric, vocal sound - but vocals are pushed more forward with less focus.
Part of my problem with the Focus pads is a lack of robustness, but there is also a lack of articulation of detail that leaves me a bit cold. Not sure if the 2Khz dip is responsible for the articulation problem or it's some other difference in the response.
My own hearing sensitivities probably play a big part - your take might be different, which is ok 
wink.gif
.
 
To be honest I think the HE6 in any form (I've heard) lacks a bit of robustness/body with vocals - compared to HD600 or, especially, my Harbeth  speakers. However the HE6 balance has its own advantages (especially for headphone listening) and the quality and clarity of the sound throughout the full range is very good.
 
Edit: In hindsight, after looking at the response graph of the HD600 it's more likely the fact that it's output only falls off very gradually into the upper mids that results in it's forwardness (compared to HE6).
Maybe the dip at 2khz with the Focus pads has less to do with lack of 'body' but is in fact responsible for the articulation shortfall. Frankly I don't know and I'm only guessing.
rolleyes.gif

Completely off topic, but further looking at the response for the AKGQ701 (which I'm familiar with) shows a peak at 2Khz which also creates a trough down into the lower mids. Now the 701 is very articulate though also lacks robustness and balance (IMO).
 
Feb 27, 2016 at 11:10 PM Post #18,378 of 21,867
I agree with Tobes.  Comparing my modded HD650 (shown below) to the HE-6 there is a much smoother frequency response that allows vocals to have a touch more body and be presented in a truly amazing way.  
 

vs HE-6 w Audeze pads
 

 
Feb 28, 2016 at 12:54 AM Post #18,379 of 21,867
   
 
vs HE-6 w mods
 

cskippy, is the graph above the modded HE6 with Audeze pads - the labelling on the graph seems to indicate stock HE6?
If modded, which mods have been applied?
 
Feb 28, 2016 at 5:12 AM Post #18,383 of 21,867
   
If you compared the HD600 to the HE6 you would know exactly what I mean.
The HD600 provides more robust, mid centric, vocal sound - but vocals are pushed more forward with less focus.
Part of my problem with the Focus pads is a lack of robustness, but there is also a lack of articulation of detail that leaves me a bit cold. Not sure if the 2Khz dip is responsible for the articulation problem or it's some other difference in the response.
My own hearing sensitivities probably play a big part - your take might be different, which is ok 
wink.gif
.
 
To be honest I think the HE6 in any form (I've heard) lacks a bit of robustness/body with vocals - compared to HD600 or, especially, my Harbeth  speakers. However the HE6 balance has its own advantages (especially for headphone listening) and the quality and clarity of the sound throughout the full range is very good.
 
Edit: In hindsight, after looking at the response graph of the HD600 it's more likely the fact that it's output only falls off very gradually into the upper mids that results in it's forwardness (compared to HE6).
Maybe the dip at 2khz with the Focus pads has less to do with lack of 'body' but is in fact responsible for the articulation shortfall. Frankly I don't know and I'm only guessing.
rolleyes.gif

Completely off topic, but further looking at the response for the AKGQ701 (which I'm familiar with) shows a peak at 2Khz which also creates a trough down into the lower mids. Now the 701 is very articulate though also lacks robustness and balance (IMO).

 

I have not found that articulation or detail is lacking with the focus pads, the opposite. What the focus pads is lacking compared to the vegans is good balance. Too much high treble and not enough bass and body.  

 

The vegan pads is picky and will sound different depending on how much you angle the pads. More angled pads mean more mid centric and closed in sound, less angled pads will result in bigger soundstage, more open and better FR balance.

 

IME

 
Feb 28, 2016 at 7:17 AM Post #18,385 of 21,867
   

I have not found that articulation or detail is lacking with the focus pads, the opposite. What the focus pads is lacking compared to the vegans is good balance. Too much high treble and not enough bass and body.  

 

The vegan pads is picky and will sound different depending on how much you angle the pads. More angled pads mean more mid centric and closed in sound, less angled pads will result in bigger soundstage, more open and better FR balance.

 

IME


Oh well I guess we hear things differently with the Focus pads, which is fine.
 
I finally decided to apply the Fuzzor mod to my HE6's tonight - I know, late again to this mod
rolleyes.gif
.
I've done very little listening at this stage (using stock velour, grill mod) but my initial reaction is positive. 
Retains the liveliness and musical engagement of the velour but more precise and perhaps spacious sound (or maybe ambient cues are just cleaner?) - definitely less tendency to brightness.
Sounding mighty fine anyway - maybe I don't need the vegans?
 
Feb 28, 2016 at 2:30 PM Post #18,386 of 21,867
  I finally decided to apply the Fuzzor mod to my HE6's tonight - I know, late again to this mod
rolleyes.gif
.
  Sounding mighty fine anyway - maybe I don't need the vegans?

Applying fuzzor was extremely tedious and time-consuming compared to the 'vegan fuzzor' mod. I also think the modded vegan pads have a far more positive effect on the sound as well as the comfort.
 
Feb 28, 2016 at 9:03 PM Post #18,387 of 21,867
Kudos on doing the fuzzor mod.  I did it to both my HE-500 and HE-6.  I ended up taking it off the HE-6 when experimenting and was hard pressed to notice a difference but there was too much time lapse to do a real comparison.  Although I wasn't crying when I pulled it off so...
 
Feb 28, 2016 at 9:43 PM Post #18,388 of 21,867
There is definitely less energy in the highs, and the soundstage is seems more sorted. But whether it is too much with the vegans remains to be heard.
May end up pulling it off - at least it's practically free.
So far, hard to criticize with the stock velour - though perhaps really well recorded material is less exciting.
 
Feb 29, 2016 at 3:21 AM Post #18,390 of 21,867
By "vegan fuzzor" I do not mean vegan pads with fuzzor applied to the driver housing. I'm talking about this: http://www.head-fi.org/t/493214/hifiman-he-6-planar-magnetic-headphone/17190#post_11864770

Yeah I understood that.
The grill modded HE6 with fuzzor on the magnets is clearly the best I've heard this headphone.
Imaging precision, especially in depth is better than I thought would be possible with the he6. Low level detail and purity is also excellent.
I feel disinclined to undo my good work.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top