So, I've had only a few chances to sit down with my new X5 so far but my initial reaction is: I'm a little disappointed. Recall that this is intended to replace, and be an upgrade for, my 1st gen X3. First, it's just doesn't sound as different as I expected. Second, it feels a bit cheaper & more flimsy than the X3, which feels more solid to me. At this point I'm starting to better appreciate the 1st X3 as a rather remarkable device that is woefully underrated around here. (imo)
These are just first impressions though. And to be fair I'm stressed & distracted with some health issues in my family, and it has also been a kinda rough weekend for my seasonal allergies. So I reserve the right to take any or all of this back and start over.
Also I did read everything you guys wrote above, and even watched most of the video from that audio conference. Very thought provoking, and even eye opening. Perhaps it's this spirit of blowing up myths keeping it real that I have the balls right now to give the X5 a bad initial review and declare the X3 superior. Lol
(I'm not actually saying that btw)
Edit:
(like, a complete, total recant edit)
After 6 months of living with the X5ii I am claiming my right to completely revise my opinion. I am now declaring a rather deep & enduring love for the X5ii.
As I said I was in a kinda rough head space in April, plus a couple other things happened. First, I had a Questyle Q1PR on loan for about a week over the summer and despite trying my hardest I could hear almost no difference between the two. Same neutral yet engaging balance, dynamics, noiseless -- all of it. I literally couldn't tell them apart (headphones used: HD600 & Focal Clear). After reading universal raves everywhere about the QP1R being far & above the best DAP to be had under $1k, this was shocking to me. I mean, I had full expectation bias in favor of the Q1PR: it was going to sound way better period. The only question would be whether I could justify the big cost difference, and could tolerate the downgrade in UI. But I sent the Questyle back quite happily, though a little confused, tbh. Maybe my hearing just isn't good enough anymore? Oh well. If FiiO is the best quality that I can discern in DAPs then good for me I guess, right? It'll save me a lot of money. (Actually I can still hear significant improvement when using my JDS/Schiit desktop rig.)
Second, I discovered that the cheap impression that I got from my X5ii was really just my X5ii. This used unit I got on ebay was very used, and pretty worn out, despite having no visible wear. The wheel and all buttons were loose & kinda rocky, the center button even being a bit sticky. I had a suspicion that this might not be the norm for these, which was confirmed when bought a second X5ii (a great deal on an old stock open box new unit). With this new unit everything was as it should be: tight, responsive, solid feeling. My faith in FiiO, restored. I am wild about this Titanium color too -- very slick!
Anyway, I am loving my new X5ii and keeping the other one as a backup (for whatever reason).
And I'm not looking forward to the day when this one wears out and I have to replace it with one of these Android-based touch screen things (i.e. a phone that doesn't make calls). I just don't like 'em, but whatever.