After combing through this long thread, I decided to take the plunge and try opamp rolling. I thought I'd share my experience. I tried the OPA2137P and the LME49720NA in the I/V section as these seem to be the most popular choices. I got major distortion with the OPA2137P so out the door they went. The LME49720NA in the I/V proved to be a major winner in my book. I have the card paired with a Matrix M-Stage amp and Grado SR-325is headphones. At first, I thought I liked the stock JRC opamps better due to what I perceived as a bigger soundstage, but after spending a few days with the LME49720NA, I think what I was hearing with the stock JRCs wasn't a bigger soundstage, but the fact that it was separating the left and right channel more than normal, giving the illusion of better soundstage, or at least better imaging. The mids and lows were also not nearly as full with the stock opamps. The added weight in the lows was a great addition to the 325is, since IMO the bass, while very good in quality, is lacking just a bit in quantity. With the LME49720s in place, there was also a slight reduction in the mid-to-upper midrange brightness. This was also a welcome addition since the Grado 325is tend to be a bit bright in that area anyways. The highs were also better defined and perhaps extended a little further, and were perhaps a little brighter than the stock opamps. Since I'm a treblehead, this too was a nice addition, though for users who find detailed highs fatiguing, this could be a con and not a plus. Overall, I am extremely happy with my entire setup now - I was considering getting another source, probably some kind of DAC that could do at least 24/96 over USB - but now I'm not going to bother. Thanks to all who made this thread great.
Edit: For a more aggressive sound (but not quite as bright/aggressive as stock), my current favorite setup is 2xLME49720NA (I/V) & 1xLM4562NA. For a nice warm somewhat laid-back sound, 2xOPA2107AP (I/V) & 1xLME49720NA.