Haha, and I do like yours also! Although I have to admit the actual character I borrowed from an image someone posted on head-fi once and then I photoshopped in the background because the original was too bland.
And indeed, the HD 800's bass is actually truly amazing with the right setups and so to answer my own question, I do believe that you can sometimes have too much of a good thing. This is why I ultimately settled down with with the HD 800 because I don't believe there is another headphone as neutral or accurate overall as the HD 800.
Comparing headphones is like comparing tvs or monitors. Some offer larger screens, some offer higher resolution and some offer both. Some might have a low refresh rate whilst some might offer lightning fast 200Hz refresh rates. Some might boast the most accurate colours whilst others might offer even more vibrant colours than real life! The only exception is the HD 800. The HD 800 is not like any tv at all. It is instead a window.
An impossibly clear window to all your music.