- Joined
- Jan 30, 2011
- Posts
- 13,315
- Likes
- 24,362
It's actually worse than that - the rips will all be at different volumes, so more than likely that is what he is hearing. He's also just doing one test and identifying rather than trying to (blind) get a statistically relevant number correct. I know regarding the volume between formats - because its one of the first things I found when I was comparing codecs.
@thepooh - thanks for posting what you did - it explains a lot - and I'm not being condescending here, I really appreciate it. Your test is flawed on a manner of fronts - but if you're happy, then that is all that really matters. I wouldn't go claiming the old golden ears badge, nor making public claims that you have successfully discerned one from the other though.
I thought this comment was enlightening
If you're really serious about finding the truth - as it relates to you - then you should be using both. Relying solely on one or the other unfortunately leads to drawing conclusions based on incomplete data. At the end of the day though - as long as you're happy - that is all that really matters.
@thepooh - thanks for posting what you did - it explains a lot - and I'm not being condescending here, I really appreciate it. Your test is flawed on a manner of fronts - but if you're happy, then that is all that really matters. I wouldn't go claiming the old golden ears badge, nor making public claims that you have successfully discerned one from the other though.
I thought this comment was enlightening
Actually, there are two types of headfiers on headfi
a. Those relying on numbers and graphs
b. Those relying on their ears
If you're really serious about finding the truth - as it relates to you - then you should be using both. Relying solely on one or the other unfortunately leads to drawing conclusions based on incomplete data. At the end of the day though - as long as you're happy - that is all that really matters.