xoxiax
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2015
- Posts
- 249
- Likes
- 173
Ok so this is just with one track but one I often use now to test SQ - a brilliantly produced, hi-res recording with everything from deep bass, to Pink Floyd-esque guitars and soaring sax - it really does demonstrate DAP/IEM capability for me. I must say, it was a tough battle - I had to listen to the track at least 5 times on each device - especially 1A vs 507. It would be better if I tested maybe another couple of genres but I don't have time tonight. All listening via my DUNU SA6. Apologies also for my lack of technical language in describing my findings!
They came out in an order I guess I would have expected -
NW-WM1A (DMP-WM1 FE Plus) - the winner (88 hours on the clock - EU device but uncapped and set to J)
There is more detail, soundstage and overall sense of 'emotion' to the music. The sax comes in on the test song around 4.30, it really grabs me and brings a smile to my face in a way unlike the others. I feel overall that there is a better emphasis across high, mid and low and just the overall delivery sounds spectacular. I noted also, especially vs the ZX300, I can continue to pump the volume up and enjoy the extra decibels - on the ZX300, it becomes harsh and I can't tolerate. Overall, I feel like I'm listening to a high-end device.
ZX507 (no hour clock but I would estimate 300+ now - Asia Pacific device)
I love this player and I find the warm nature of it's signature is stunning. I would say I actually prefer it to the stock 1A but with custom firmware, it does change things - definitely a greater sense of detail, soundstage etc as noted above - I had observed this difference even on 1A stock but it was too bright then (this could be to do with burn-in also as still less than 100 hours on the 1A). The emotion is there on the 507 and the warm signature is so easy to listen to, just a really smooth sound that I can listen to for hours.
ZX300 (Project Z Plus) (1445 hours on the clock - EU device uncapped and set to J)
The ZX300 is definitely behind both, it sounds brighter and maybe a little lifeless in comparison. I don't get that same sense of 'wow' as I do on the others - the emotion I noted in the 1A just doesn't show up in the same way. Don't get me wrong, it still sounds great but doing this A/B/C test does show up the differences. Again though, it could probably do with more genres tested - I suspect the ZX300 might do better on more vocal, acoustic genres.
As I think I've said in the thread already, I can't see the ZX300 getting much use now but I still wouldn't part with it - those 1445 hours clocked up represent a lot of happy listening at home, on holidays, work trips, buses, trains, walks etc etc!
Test track:
Many, many millions of thanks for your generous answer! And specially for that "lack of technical language" that highlights the feelings provided by each machine when listening to music. That subjective thing called pleasure doesn't know much about objective measurements and, from my point of view, sharing in common that diverse subjective perceptions we all have is the furthest we can achieve in this forum while trying to approach the final goal of all this neurotic hobby: finding the equipment that fits our tastes (and wallet possibilities) to enjoy our music (well, at least supposedly, because being honest with ourselves different consumerism pathologies that allow us evasion and displace from other life's matters would have a strongest explanatory power about what we are doing here...).
Reading you and considering different opinions spilled on the forum since all this mods revitalized the non android Sonys, my impression (just speculative, only the people that has all the daps can confirm it) is that the most benefited player from Mr. Walkman's intervention has been the WM1A, whose hardware was maybe the less exploited (i don't know if my poor english tricks me here, i want to express that the software took less advantage of it's possibilities) with the custom firmware and tuning.
It seems that the massive response from WM1A owners describes now a bigger gap with it's follower (ZX300) and a closer one with it's reference (WM1Z), resolving a problem of underused potential...But maybe there are different impressions that i'd love to know...
Last edited: