I agree, the HE1000S is very very good too. On that day, I had my slightly modified Edition XS with me.from a personal view I think the LCD-XC21 is a fantastic closed back... it beats the LCD-X .... probably the best value in open backs right now is the Hifiman HE1000 Stealth that is being released at $1999 ... its a pretty amazing headphone... if you have a LCD-XC21 and a HE1000 Stealth you pretty much have a end game... depending on DAC/Amp mating...
I confidently say, it sounded better than a factory EDXS, even reps from Hifiman agreed, they even took some pictures of the mods. and questioned me at some length about them. Some lucky guy has just bought it off me. I didn't need it after I got my XC.
However, the difference between EDXS and the HE1000S was not all that much! even less with mine.
As good as HE1000S is, the EDXS is much better value, probably the best value headphone in Hifiman range.
For the money, I can't think of another that beats it.