The Sensaphonics seal test consists of playing a 50 Hz tone and a 500 Hz tone. The results are the same as the previous test I did; the 50 Hz tone is barely there, and the 500 Hz tone is clear and loud. I have manually pushed the earphones into my ear and held them at the best possible angle to get the best possible bass response, and they still fail miserably. The shape (and material) of the GR10 tips is so similar to the Klipsch S4, that I have a very difficult time believing my seal is the problem. I even took the S4 tips and crammed them onto the GR10, and I barely noticed a difference.
I will say that the GR10 does not isolate as well as the Klipsch S4's do. If I rub my fingers together, I can hear them a bit more when wearing the GR10. It's quite noticeable. Typing is louder when wearing the GR10. But I really feel like the bass response should be better regardless of the isolation. In other words, I think I have a good, airtight seal. If I sit the S4 on the edge of my ears, such that the isolation is worse than the GR10, the bass response is still better. Three or four times the perceived volume!
I've contacted Grado, who has referred me to the local distributer. We'll see what happens.
When I ran the frequency sweep again, I noticed there was a clear hump between 2500 and 3200 Hz too (I didn't really pay much attention to those ranges the first time I tried). I also tried again with the Klipsch S4, and they are smooth almost the whole way through (slight peak around 7800 Hz, but not as strong as either hump on the GR10).