Yes, I agree this is a problematic recording, but it doesn't ring at all with either of my Stax rigs, even though e-stats in general tend to have some 1-4kHz forwardness. Also, it doesn't ring with the HD650 and HD590. It does ring with the D7200 and TH900 stock versions, and much less with the mods.
If your point is that you don't hear this type of ringing with most music and recording you are listening to, that is setting exactly the point I wanted to arrive to: one cannot take one single context and call out on a flaw of a given headphone (unless describing the limits of the context carefully). However, that doesn't mean there is no problem
.