*Mini review of the Cambridge DacMagic Plus+ vs Nuforce Icon HDP*
Just some quick impressions over 2 hours or so of a brand new un-boxed Cambridge DacMagic Plus, I decided to
pitch it against a close competitor - the Nuforce Icon HDP which carries a street price of $669AUD RRP versus the
DacMagic Plus' pricetag of $699AUD RRP.
Unboxing and general pictures
[size=small]
Testing Notes[/size]
I decided to use 3 headphones across this comparo' to see how the Cambridge would fare across
a range of very different higher end headphones.
Audio Technica A2000X
Sennheiser HD650
Sennheiser HD800
The first dilemma was deciding upon an input method, the Cambridge DacMagic comes with it's own
USB cable but I was aware of the USB input's limitations (capped at 16 44/48). Hence I decided
to use the Audiophilleo 1 USB to SPDIF converter, just in case ~ after much deliberation early
on in the test, I reverted back to using USB to USB for both the DacMagic Plus and Nuforce Icon HDP.
This was primarily because the Cambridge is a native upsampler and once connected via Coax
will lock you into upsampling any material to 192Khz ~ this proved to be detrimental on most test
tracks to my ears.
General Listening Impressions
The first thing that strikes you is the 'spin through' volume dial on the DacMagic Plus, there is no
marker and no reference for where the volume lies, it is strongly advisable for anyone considering
this unit to always play the headphones away from your head, there is simply no way of telling
where the volume sits. The following tracks were used for comparison :-
Kevin Eubanks ~ Angel with the blues (funk guitar instrumental)
Daft Punk ~ Verdis Quo (electronic no vocals)
Rage Against the Machine ~ Bullet in the head (funk heavy metal)
Unknown high quality track from HDtracks.com ~ Over the rainbow (cover, acoustic female vocal)
Filter settings :- Linear, Min, and Steep are very difficult to pick between on the fly, I ended up
selecting the default 'Linear' mode, no doubt extended listening would reveal a personal preference.
The Nuforce set a surprising, cracking pace with all three headphones,
I was most surprised with the HD800 performance which by no means
extracted the true possibilities of this headphone but most importantly
gave a taste of the separation and floating sound stage that these cans
are renowned for ~ the same could not be said for the DacMagic Plus.
While the HDP from Nuforce added 'weight' and impact to the bass
lines and filled in the mids with detail, especially background content
~ the DacMagic persisted with a thin, 2D landscape of sound, lacking
a tonne of detail. Bass was the most disappointing across the electronic
track from Daft Punk ~ it was merely a dull thud on the DacMagic, towards
the end of that particular track there is opportunity for the HD800's sound
stage to shine ~ it did on the Nuforce, but it just blended into the background
with the DacMagic.
Lack of extension summed up the DacMagic's general presentation, while
the general tone from the headphone out suited my preference for a neutral
to bright sound versus the slightly warm, meaty presentation from the Nuforce
~ the HDP consistently in back to back auditioning showed that it was superior
in extracting the most with the track at hand. The only time that the race grew
close was with the 'Over the rainbow' (cover) where this female vocal was
conveyed somewhat clearly and authentically with the DacMagic, however
small breaths, pauses and lip smacks went to the Nuforce while this sort
of detail flew over the DacMagic's DAC radar.
The head amp section of the DacMagic started to intrigue me for all the
wrong reasons, was it the amp or the DAC responsible for this lack lustre
performance?
Source: Cambridge Audio website
Headphone output | |
THD: | at 1kHz 0dBFS 24 bit signal with 22kHz low pass filter = 0.001%
at 20khz 0dBFS 24 bit signal with 80kHz low pass filter = 0.003% |
S/N: | -111dBrA |
Frequency Response: | 10Hz - 100kHz |
| Recommend headphones with impedance between 32 Ohm to 600 Ohm. |
Are these specifications acceptable on a $699AUD Dac/Amp? Not really.
General early conclusions
I am more than aware that this impression will raise the ire and tyranny of many a Cambridge die hard
fan, I am left with only two possibilities :-
a) This unit was faulty, I have only heard this unit.
b) Burn in exists and if you believe in it, start praying now.
If it is any consolation, out of the 4 people (myself included) who heard this fresh unit today
~ 1 of the 4 thought that the DacMagic Plus sounded more authentic and communicative to his
ears than the Nuforce HDP.
I really wish to re-visit it some time soon as I feel that I have nothing really positive to say
about the Cambridge DacMagic Plus ~ it was dynamically outgunned by the HDP, and that's
even before we've considered the Audio GD NFB-5 at $450AUD landed ~ $250 less ~ which
from memory would have this DacMagic Plus for breakfast.
I also wonder whether this is a signature note from the Wolfson WM8740's ~ first time I'd
heard a dual setup from that series, I'm more familiar with the WM8741 and WM8742.
Given a lack of improvement in future this unit to my ears should be compared with a Fiio E9 and E10 DAC,
it cannot play in the $400+ bracket.
Ok, I'm ready for the rotten vegetables now...
As always, none of this would of been possible (the impressions, if generally negative) without the generous help
and resources from George and his expansive audition room at 'Addicted to Audio' in Kew, Melbourne