I've only tried 0db and down -12db. I won't use +db. Too powerful.
-12db gives me an excellent range on the volume control. On the Hawks volume gets near half way. On the LCD-3 it gets near the top with room to spare.
With 0db I don't have much volume control. Hawks are a few clicks up from the bottom. LCD-3 is one third up. A little adjustment on the volume can take the volume from just about right to blasting my ears.
My first sound impressions from the different positions. Not a lot of difference. Hawks I can't pick up anything. LCD-3 does sound just a tad leaner on -12db. In the mid-range. Not a lot tho.
So 0db sounds best so far. However I think I like the Hawks best on the V281 so far. So I would probably prefer to have more volume range (the -12db position). I'm thinking of keeping the LCD-3's for tube amp duties only as the LCD-3's beat the Hawks on tubes.
Yeah, this looks like the difference in personal preferences.
I use LCD-3F and Beyerdynamic DT 770 Pro 250.
This headphones are from different price points, but I cannot actually tell if one is better than other.
They both have the strengths and weaknesses, and have different tonal balance.
Anyway, I have the same impressions from both about the pregain settings.
The sound @ -12 dB
seems to be more precise or accurate.
@ 0 dB it seems to have more so-called fullness (I think this is that some people talked about V281 in the reviews, and probably you talk about the same thing).
@ 0 dB the sound is concentrated more on each instrument and its environment, @ -12 dB it is more about the global scene.
That difference is not like day and night. It may be described like fine tuning of the sound.
I used this setup with LCD-3 in relatively noisy environment, and I preferred -12 dB.
Now I have quiet environment, and this changed my preference to 0 dB (maybe temporarily).
0 dB seems to be more about music =)
I use Violectric V800 with 24 dBu outputs, so, I don't turn the volume higher than 12 o'clock.
I don't see the problem here, because the sound remains the same at the different positions of the volume knob.