After 2h, these my initial thoughts of the u4s/module 15 vs Monarch Mk2:
- detail/mids- the MMk2 are definitely more resolving, cleaner and pinpoint, very sharply separated in mids (well they probably have one of the best midranges on the market right now, so the bar is set very high. The MMk2 beat the u12t in this area for me so..). But i dont think i can hear less with the u4s. They just have a different tuning and they are still very satisfying so im happy. Vocals on the u4s are pushed back on the stage, so it can be because of that.
- trebles- the MMk2 have buttery smooth trebles but the u4s have more air region which is fantastic due to the Tia driver. Amazing, delicate detail up on a very top.
- bass- the u4s win here hands down. The MMk2 have very prominent subbass but it shows up only in specific recordings, where on the u4s the midbass and subbass are always prominent, giving a great depth and drive to the stage and sound overall.
- soundstage- the MMk2 seem wider because of a very clean and open midrange. The u4s are deeper and more 3D, wrapping around my head. But there are moments when the sounds appear far right/left, beyond my shoulders so seems like the u4s have a potential to spread the soundstage far in this directions but they do it only when the recording calls for it.
- dynamics- the u4s are winning here, having even blacker background and showing very clearly differences between louder and quieter instruments. Amazing! Very moody, slightly darker and calmer but still neutral sound, without significant coloration. Great punch too where the MMk2 are leaner overall.
- engagement- for me the u4s are a keeper definitely. They are calmer, more relaxed but still very enjoyable listening. The Monarchs are more into my face with gobes of detail and sharp separation, with rawer presentation. They are like experiencing music live in the outdoor enviroment when the u4s are more moody, like listening to the performance in a very big club/hall. The MMk2 can become fatiguing after a while, where the u4s draw me into the music the more i listen to.
The u4s are almost the same as the u12t in their presentation but with better bass and slightly better tuned treble but less resolving. Actually for me the resolution is the only factor where the u4s slightly loses to the u12t.
Im amazed actually.