Hey!
I dont write to often here. There are many reasons, but mostly, I am focused on music consumption. Just recently... I decided that maybe its time to expand my hardware... my Z5's right piece started to break up. Eventually I lost it 4 months ago. My basic setup was MW-ZX507 -> Kimber Sony cable balanced -> XBA-Z5.
I went wild and bought Focal Clear, IE300, then borrowed some other multi DAC Dap, Final Audio A8000 and finally IER-Z1r. All that to finally move on from my old love. Z5's were dead. I spent weeks listening to that equipment. I learned a lot about my self, but also about the whole thing I call a hunger for more. More of something. So here are my thoughts.
Focal Clear, at least connected to what I have is... fine I guess. Its very organic sounding headphones, with some frequency issues, and a bit of muddy mid-tones and lack of lower end. I did listen to it attached to 507, H6, Atom, Arche ( in shop, best case so far ), Ipad, Dragonfly. Whats amazing that it sounds totally different with any source. Stage is hyper small, but its an ok headphones. Not epic though. I will get back to it. I love their physical form though...
Never, ever I got so hooked up to music with those though. Never. They are... fine , but I always feel them as a transition to music. They don't disappear and fact that they are open, is not helping much. Could be my source.
IE300, my daily headphones, apart from Momentum TW, are a very very comfortable headphones, with somewhat recessed midtones, and rather dead and yet bright highs. By dead I mean they dont resolve a lot, and yet they do shout a tiny bit. As an outcome, I like them a lot but feel they dont got my heart as most of Sennheiser headphones, like Momentum IE, Momentum 3 or TW. And all of them are "more mainstream". Odd. Still, I use IE300 but they are really far from what I was getting with Z5.
Final a8000 are very interesting, as , as super bright as they are, and totally different than Z5's as they are, they do have one common thing to Z5's, they do feel super coherent. They are not my cup of tea, but I respect them a lot, for being full on with fast, bright presentation, though heavily lifted to my ears. Lack of base foundation meant I did not get in to film scores at all.
Finally, Z1r. I had an option to buy them, with a great price as a second hand. I did listen to them a LOT out of 507 via balanced. I was instantly blown away by highs, amazing fluid highs. And that stage... holographic stage.. INFINITE one!!! In comparison with Focal its like... ice vs lava. Incredible Highs!!!!
There are many reviews of Z1r... mostly saying how amazing these are. I honestly felt I am being fooled by them a bit. They do have that stellar technical capabilites in highs, with hyper smooth , organic highs, and amazing base performance. All that plus stage makes it feel ... surreal. Hyper realistic at times... but when I do listen to tracks I know well from many sources, and have that.. sort of avarage perception of track.. I feel I am missing something with Z1r.. they are hyper real and yet not realistic. I felt that I do miss a weight of mids, but not in Freq response, I tried that, I felt that they do not go from mid tones to highs the right way. They dont feel coherent, I do feel , apart from stellar details in highs and again that stage <3 !!! , the gap. All, hidden behind that sweetness of the technical capabilities ( even after many weeks I was always overwhelmed ). That made a lot of my tracks stellar, but not really emotional. On a positive side, they do sound energetic, but never harsh. I would call them slightly shouty at time to me , but always classy.
I was hours before getting in to : I buy Z1r, and maybe Sell Focal. And then, I took my old Z5, plugged Kimber to them one last time, and tried to play the same song I did kill with Z1r.. and when I felt it will not work, for a brief moment my broken earpiece started to work ( Bent head .. dont move mode ).... and I felt it.... stage felt considerably smaller, highs, lost a bit of presence, decay and fluidity, but mids got back right were they were missing... and suddenly Z1r sounded artificial i comparison, Focal great but kind of dead and muddy, IE300 cool but soulless... Yes Z5 's are not on the same technical level as Z1r, but I really would say they sound more coherent, more organic, and more musical than Z1r to my ears. Maybe I am not super in to highs? I did have a long break , few months break and almost 6 weeks with Z1r.. but in a blind test I would pick Z5 any day...regardless of price.
I did buy a new Z5 on Ebay for 500Euro and plan to sell almost new Focal Clear if anyone os interested.... just saying.. that in my eyes, resolution or technical perfection is not what makes me happy listening to music. Another thing that hit me is that reviews, as good as they are...should always be a hint, not a whole truth in buying decision. I was lucky enough to be able to test its. Z5 rocks. They really do rock. ( and all other genres if needed).