castleofargh
Sound Science Forum Moderator
- Joined
- Jul 2, 2011
- Posts
- 10,444
- Likes
- 6,064
Anyone received the Sony newsletter booklet via regular mail? It mentions the A10 as Their first audiophile player! Kinda puts doubt where the ZX1 belongs.
This depends where you live, if you are in an area which retails the ZX1 on the sony website then first audiophile player tag is odd, but if you live in the US or any other area which never carried the ZX1, then the A10 is the first audiophile player.
Although, the ZX1 was always a limited edition device, designed for the 35th anniversary of the Walkman, so technically not a series, just a stand alone model.
Same could be said for the X-Series, was released in 2009, when the walkman had it's 30th anniversary but it was not mentioned as an anniversary model I believe.
I though about that too, as they did with some products years ago that were available only on the sony store online and nowhere to be found in stores, they often tagged the underdog in store as the best or the first something. but that wouldn't explain the F866 not being the first.
@tenedosian I mostly agree with your findings, like the F886 having the most width, the X3 the smallest but more depth (height could be counted to as the X3 doesn't have much and often gets voices and drums on the same disturbing axis). to me this is explained by some crosstalk or crossfeed, anything that would significantly impact the stereo separation. great stereo should sound unnatural on headphones, a little like the F886. and I suspect that most DAPs (on purpose or not) push the sounds forward a little by mixing channels. in that effort the X3 has abused that idea in my opinion.
about the bass, if I again agree with your conclusion, I would like to say that the reason is not that much the signatures of the DAPs. it's just that the sony has like 50 times less power compared to others and that would obviously have consequences at some point on your headphones. unlike what could happen with IEMs where the DX50 would still sound with flattish to rolled off bass, when the F886 kicks b-asses in most situations with low clean bass, but can't keep up at all on a harder to drive fullsize headphone.
and plugging the F886 into an amp shows immediately that it's very much about power and not signature.
but overall I'm just being picky on the reasons, I agree with the observations. it's a good analysis and a lot of people talking on the respective DAP topics could learn a thing or two from your post.