>
Feature Impressions
GENERAL IMPRESSIONS
I do commercial product design for a living. I even have Digital Audio Player experience, designing the player UX and the desktop software for the world’s first Wi-Fi enabled MP3 player. We launched with over-the-air sync of
Audible.com content and your own library. The player was a CES 2004 Best of Show Finalist. The industrial design on that DAP unit was laughable, but we were a small start-up and it takes real money to build a slim, elegant hardware package.
Here’s the CNET review:
CNET Editor’s Review (
https://www.cnet.com/reviews/soniqcast-element-aireo-1-5gb-review/)
So, I will make a few subjective comments on the NW-A55.
No one does consumer electronics industrial design (ID) better than Sony. You can try to change my mind, but good luck. I’ve met with Engineering Directors from Sony in the TV division and ID is hard-wired into their culture.
However, Sony struggles with software UX, for both the player and their accompanying desktop software. And, I admit my bias here: I have a long history of dealing with Sony’s crappy software, going back to the MiniDisc days in the mid-‘90s.
The “Content Transfer for Mac” application is just… well, I can’t believe anyone uses it. Note to Sony: look at Doug’s Scripts and an app called M3Unify to see how transferring music from iTunes is done well. I will cover that in my follow-on post: macOS to Walkman workflow. But it sort-of doesn’t matter, because you can just connect your player to your Mac/PC and drag-and-drop, assuming you have a WM-PORT cable handy.
I feel like Sony has turned a corner with the UX on the A55. They finally equipped the DAP with a processor powerful enough to support smooth scrolling with a large collection of audio tracks. The touch screen is responsive, album art looks very sharp, the fonts are crisp and readable, and control layout is just right.
Small touches are there, too, like the settings pop-up menu being shifted right and down for an easy reach with your thumb, assuming you are right-handed.
Bluetooth receiver setup was two taps and easy to understand. The main menu icons (on the bottom, during playback) are great - one tap access to top-level menu, current playing track, settings and always a back button. Seriously, I have zero complaints on the player UI; my clients was be quite surprised to read that statement
BROWSING & PLAYBACK
One of my biggest complaints with the NWZ-A17 is that browsing by Artist is just that, and not by the far more useful Album Artist.
With the NW-55, there is a setting to toggle between Artists and Album Artists (hallelujah … I was almost ready to buy a 40 series for that feature, alone). Otherwise, Play Mode and Playback Range seem to match how the A17 functioned.
Browsing is fast and completely smooth - similar to using a music app on my iPad Pro. There is a very brief delay to render album art in the background, but it does not interfere with scrolling (swiping up/down). Swiping is as fast as you can flip your finger.
You can also grab the “scroll thumb” and see an alphabetic overlay (i.e. (A) on the ‘A’ parts of the list). This makes scrolling though large collections very fast.
Scrubbing the playback progress bar during playback works as I expected and it’s very smooth. I like to re-listen to things like guitar riffs, over and over again, and the scrubber UI was nicely designed for people like me.
Well done, Sony.
Looking through my collection of music (albums, playlists), which is about 170GB on a microSD card, I am seeing 100% coverage on album art. However, note that I went thought the process of ensuring that all album art is “Baseline JPG” - something I did with the A17. So, no surprise for me, but YMMV.
I’ve read a number of complaints on Head-Fi from Walkman users reporting album display problems, not being aware of the progressive JPG display issue. I am too lazy to load some tracks with progressive JPG album art, so if this *has* been fixed with the A55, I apologize for the above comment. Otherwise, Sony needs to do better.
A second complaint browsing with the A17 - navigating into Genre displays the Artist collection (that’s fine). Navigating into the Artist shows you that Album Artist’s albums - sorted by title (that’s cool, too).
But, going into "Genre - All" is a complete list of songs - not the albums in alphabetical order. Bummer that this hasn’t changed with the A55. I listen to a lot of classical music and I can’t always recall the Album Artists for an album, but I sure can remember the album art and/or title. So, I like to browse into “Classical Violin” and then see all of the albums at once. I guess I will have to keep dreaming on that one…
SOUND SETTINGS
Happy to see that ClearAudio+ is still on the device - I thought I had read that this feature was absent, but it’s there (and it’s fun to use with some music).
The EQ works as you would expect. There are presets and you can create custom settings. Again, the UI here was simple and intuitive. Though, to be honest, I was listening to London Grammar tracks while playing around with the EQ presets and I didn’t find one that I liked better than OFF. I understand that you have to give your brain time to adjust to a new sound; I didn’t do that, so YMMV.
There are a number of options: DSEE HX, DC Phase Linearizer, VPT (Surround), Dynamic Normalizer, Vinyl Processor. I left all of these off - I listen to analog tapes and records in real life; I don’t know what to do with a *vinyl processor* for digital audio tracks.
Just kidding… I had to try the Vinyl Processor. I was half-expecting to hear fake vinyl surface noise, but the effect is subtle. I’m not sure what that DSP is doing, but with many of the tracks from my previous post, I couldn’t hear anything immediate. That is, until I played Hilary Hahn Plays Bach (2018) (Redbook from CD). When I listened to that album yesterday with the Shure SE535s, I was experiencing listening fatigue about 1/2-way through the album.
So, I tried this again, but with the Vinyl Processor toggled on. I am *guessing* that the Vinyl Processor rolls off the highs and maybe adds a little distortion?
According to Sony: "The newly developed Vinyl Processor feature recreates via some clever processing, the acoustic phenomenon unique to vinyl playback such as the tone-arm resonance, tiny surface noise and the rich sound from the vibration by acoustic feedback from the speakers to the turntable."
Huh. This setting sounds nothing like anything I’ve experienced on my Rega RP3, but OK. I may have heard “tiny surface noise" on an old recording of Jacqueline du Pré, but that could also be on the original recording. But, I will say this: I found "Hilary Hahn Plays Bach” a more pleasing experience though the Shure SE535 IEMs with the Vinyl Processor enabled. I’ve left it on.
BLUETOOTH USAGE
Super easy to setup. You tap on the little icon on the top-right (phone with waves), you tap on OK and it reconnects. Done. On the first connect, you pair it with your phone, just like you would with any other speaker or headphones. Best of all, the NW-A55 DSP settings are all available while playing back bluetooth audio from your phone.
My Pixel 2 and the NW-A55 both report an LDAC connection. I am pleasantly surprised that it all works. Again, mission accomplished, as this was the second use case that drove my purchase of the NW-A55 (first being a DAP that does a better job driving my Shure SE535 IEMs).
FINAL CONCLUSION
Sony has restored my faith in Walkman. Yes, it took five major releases, but whatever.
I feel sorry for people that are growing up listening to heavily compressed music on an iPhone with Apple EarPods. This is my 16 year-old daughter. When I can get her to try my desktop rig, her reaction is always: “...wow, that’s amazing…", but no interest in changing how she listens to music. I tried buying her some nice ‘phones, but she really wanted Beats because … yeah.
Could this replace my desktop rig? Hard no. Will I stop carrying my PHA-3 with me when I travel? Soft yes - with my Shure IEMs, yes; with my Sony MDR-Z7, no (especially when using the balanced cable with the Z7).
Will the battery life live up to my expectations (i.e. travel without a WM-PORT cable and needing to recharge every workday)? We will find out, as the NW-A55 takes its place as my daily driver.
Thanks for reading and congratulations to Sony on a great iteration in the Walkman line!
End Note: I was not prompted/compensated to write anything on Head-Fi - it's a hobby for me, I like to write, and I just wanted to share.