Just joining this thread...haven't read all of it yet (but will tackle at least part of it).
Listening to a modded pair of HD650s right now. I've never heard the stock HD650 or Massdrop HD6XX. Have the stock earcups here & when I'm done deep-dive listening to the mods, will try them stock.
But here's the thing: I've heard about the HD650 for years but never managed to hear on until earlier this year (in modded form)--and I'm impressed as hell. Hard to pin down why this sound is so appealing: there's no flash or sizzle, no gimmicks, no concussion syndrome bass here. All I know is I put these headphones on, then a couple hours later, have difficulty taking them off. In the past month or so, I've put almost all my headtime into these modded HD650s, not my own beloved Ori or X2s.
It's all about the music, not the headphones...and these headphones are somehow giving me a very pleasing sonic "view" of all kinds of music. Haven't found a single genre that doesn't satisfy on these headphones.
Eventually I'll post a review on Head-Fi about this particular HD650 mod. But in the meantime: Sennheiser (and the fellow who modded these)--you have my complete attention.