Which of the three would you recommend to an avid rock listener? Bands I primarily listen to are in my profile, if you need a frame of reference (it only includes bands I listen to more than a few singles from).
Nice list
- we share a similar taste for Grunge. I absolutely love Seether, Nirvana, and Pearl Jam - especially Vedder (favourite male vocalist).
Let me see - what kind of sound do you like? Quick down and dirty description:
HD600 = open, airy but not overly expansive/ more decay (often perceived as slower), neutralish - but not flat, very natural sounding (most realistic timbre and tone), bassiest of the 3 as far as impact goes - but it's primarily mid-bass.
Weaknesses = can sometimes sound a little polite, a little slow, and a little thumpy - I still rank it as technically the best overall sounding of the three.
DT880 = open, airy, again not overly expansive, brighter and perception of more detail than HD600 (this is only perception IMO), a lot flatter / more neutral, faster, better bass quality than the HD600, and more extended both ends.
Weaknesses = can sometimes be overly bright and etched, mid-range can also be perceived as sometimes being recessed - it's not - it's just that the signature overall is the most neutral of the three
K701/2 = open, airy, expansive, DT880 is brighter overall, but AKG sits behind it, very fast (faster than DT880 IMO), least bass of the 3 - but very high quality bass, mids are slightly elevated, but I find them very natural - maybe even a little euphoric.
Weaknesses = soundstage is almost too big, and can be a little left/center/right rather than circular, if underpowered bass can go AWOL (right amp and the bass is fantastic), some have called the mids plasticky or false (I always loved them) - least comfortable of the three
For Seether I'd probably pick the DT880 or K701, for PJ it would be the HD600, for Nirvana could be any of the 3.
Safest for Rock would probably be the DT880 - but safest isn't necessarily the best.
Sorry - probably didn't help much. You need to see if you can hear all 3 side by side. IMO HD600 and DT880 are good with either tubes or SS. K701/2 are definitely at their best with a high current SS amp.