New on the forums and at buying decent headphones in general. Just got a pair of Fidelio X2HR from Amazon UK, like new (and they indeed look new) at a very good price, 112 Pounds compared to 160 new. First time listening to them I liked the sound but then I did some comparing with a pair of Audio Tehnica ATH-MSR7 I have and my impression is that the X2 fall short in clarity, bass and especially volume.
From what I read the MSR7 have rather subdued bass for a closed back and the X2 should be quite bassy for an open back but the bass from the MSR7 is way punchier and tight compared to the X2. Is there that much of a difference in this regard between a closed back and an open one? Could be that my ears are not used to open backs (never had one until now) and need some more listening to pick up on it? I know comparing open backs with closed is complicated but still.
What seem even weirder to me and makes me think I could have gotten a damaged pair is the volume issue and this is not debatable like the bass or clarity. Running them both from a FiiO K3, for the X2 I have to turn the volume up way higher compared to the MSR7s to hear them as loud. Both having the same impedance, does this sound normal? I imagine that leaking sound from the open backs X2 would result in lower perceived volume but the difference is really big. My main worry is that I got a damaged pair and, not having listened to many decent headphones and no other open backs at all, it's kinda hard to tell. What should I listen more closely to to tell for sure they are technically fine?
How does the above sound to you experienced people here? Any opinions or information on the matter would be really useful, if sounds like a damaged pair I'll return ii and order another. Sorry if I posted in the wrong place, this seems to be the main X2 thread around here.
Thanks in advance
Listened a bit more to the 2 head to head, mostly to Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd and Tom Waits. Activating gain on the K3 helped a bit with volume, but even with gain it's at 70% or so depending on the song. To hear as loud, the MSR7 stay at 60% or less and with gain active. And gain does increase volume by quite a bit. The voice is more upfront and clear, there's more detail and the bass is definitely more punchy on the MSR7. The X2 sound a bit more natural and there's the sensation of space, which I assume is to be expected. Sorry I cannot describe it better, it might be actually possible that those differences are normal for open vs close and it's just the fact that I'm not used to open backs?