Comparison is vs my old Perreaux SHX-1. 12 years on it and I know it pretty well.
Source is Modi 2.
Cans are NAD VISO HP50s
Vali 2 is on low gain. Pot is at about 2 o'clock.
Stock tube has 2 hours on it. I know that's not a fair deal but... eh.. I'm underwhelmed.
Bass is like, ghosty. It's there, it's present, but it has no slam. no presence. no force.
Treble is a bit sharp for my tastes. It's cutting through the music.
Midrange is overemphasized, but not very sweet. A couple songs where the guitars should be tickling me... they just aren't.
Separation is good at least.
Soundstage is ok, not great.
Overall, the toe-tapping, warm-hug, sound I was looking for isn't there.
I know I should give the stock tube more time, but I've got the Philips PCC88 sitting right here looking at me. I'll give it a chance.
edit:
45 minutes on the Philips PCC88, and it's a pretty big difference. Biggest change is that instantly the harshness of the stock tube is gone.
Sharp Treble is reined in, without much, if any, loss of detail. Maybe it's my imagination, but I think there's some sparkle in there now where there was harshness before. Still not perfect, but much improved.
Midrange is sweeter for sure. It's still not quite what I was looking for, but way better than stock. It seems more controlled and less "bloaty" (which isn't something I normally think of as characteristic of midrange). I already notice a bit of a difference even from when I first started listening, so maybe it's going to get even better. Both Female and Male vocals are more pleasing than before.
Separation and Soundstage... wow. just wow. There are instruments fully out of my head now. This is as good as I've ever heard the Soundstage on these cans, and I've listened to them on a WA-7. This is so trippy. I could get used to this.
The Bass is, well, it's still less than what I know these cans can do, but it's getting better. It's certainly more controlled than the stock tube, but not much more presence/slam. Have to see what it sounds like at around the 40 hour range or so.
I know I should give the stock tube its fair chance, with a long burn-in and all, but it's going to be damn hard for me to convince myself to pry the PCC88 out to do so.
Last quick edit before bed:
I have indeed caught myself toe-tapping and head bobbing several times now with the PCC88.
Bass is fleshing out a bit. Mid-bass is superb, really natural and present. Bass Guitars sound so so good. The Vali2/PCC88/HP50 combo rips through classic Rock. Eagles, Floyd, Who, Aerosmith, AC/DC, etc sound like I'm stage with the band.