HamilcarBarca
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2012
- Posts
- 1,027
- Likes
- 41
Quote:
For the most part, it appears to be a fair review.
I've been reading ODAC reviews for months, but this is the first claim of such noise I've seen. I've never heard such a noise. He states he hears noise when the ODAC "has a lot of work to do to sort everything out", but what is that supposed to mean? He's also an "op-amp roller". These don't reflect well on the reliability of his conclusions, in my opinion.
It doesn't matter how good (or bad) something sounds to one reviewer, another reviewer will have the opposite opinion. Before going on a single review, or on my recommendation, see how many other reviewers agree.
Edit: I have no reason to believe the ODAC produces better audio than the DACMini LX or vice versa. Clearly, the LX has features the ODAC lacks. It might even have better build quality, not that I think the ODAC is lacking. In fact, if their DACMini CX (not LX) was priced similarly to the ODAC+O2, I would have seriously considered it.
I'm just worried that some reviews, such as this one:
http://www.head-fi.org/t/626615/centrance-dacport-lx-vs-ibasso-db2-boomslang-2-vs-jds-labs-objective-dac
say that the ODAC has problems such as this:
the highly resolving, otherwise very neutral and transparent Objective DAC throws little fits from time to time that are very annoying. This momentary aberrant behavior seems to occur whenever there's a particularly loud high frequency signal during an instant of high-complexity, where the DAC has a lot of work to do to sort everything out. It's as if the ODAC just gives up, momentarily, and renders those instantaneous high frequencies like two blocks of styrofoam being rubbed together - to produce a very short in duration, but very loud distortion of information that the LX and the PB2 have no difficulty rendering cleanly.
For the most part, it appears to be a fair review.
I've been reading ODAC reviews for months, but this is the first claim of such noise I've seen. I've never heard such a noise. He states he hears noise when the ODAC "has a lot of work to do to sort everything out", but what is that supposed to mean? He's also an "op-amp roller". These don't reflect well on the reliability of his conclusions, in my opinion.
It doesn't matter how good (or bad) something sounds to one reviewer, another reviewer will have the opposite opinion. Before going on a single review, or on my recommendation, see how many other reviewers agree.
Edit: I have no reason to believe the ODAC produces better audio than the DACMini LX or vice versa. Clearly, the LX has features the ODAC lacks. It might even have better build quality, not that I think the ODAC is lacking. In fact, if their DACMini CX (not LX) was priced similarly to the ODAC+O2, I would have seriously considered it.