1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.

    Dismiss Notice

Meridian Explorer DAC/Amp Stream of Consciousness Review (WARNING: Not Good)

Discussion in 'Portable Headphone Amps' started by purrin, Feb 25, 2013.
First
 
Back
1 2 3
5 6 7 8 9 10
Next
 
Last
  1. RexAeterna

    i'm wondering the same thing.
     
  2. Keevs
    For a technical newbie, what does a high output Z mean in terms if listening experience?
     
  3. gelocks
    Quote:
     
    Wow... so it's official then, purrin does NOT have a busted unit.... oh well.
     
  4. MoonUnit
    Quote:
     
    It means that the amp essentially applies a headphone-dependent tone control (equalization curve) to the sound you hear. In many cases, this will mean the sound is more "midrangey" and with rolled off highs than an amp that is accurate. The effect will be more pronounced on low and medium impedance headphones, and most pronounced on low impedance IEMs with multiple drivers and crossover networks.
     
    Also, it means that the bass will be poorly damped (wooly instead of tight). Some people perceive this as a more "bodacious" bass that they find pleasing, but it is not particularly accurate.
     
    DoomForce, Currawong, jgray91 and 2 others like this.
  5. Tyll Hertsens Contributor
    ^^^^Like.  Good summary.
     
  6. MoonUnit
    Quote:
     
    It also means that Purrin has much better hearing than Computer Audiophile's Chris Connaker, Audiostream's Michael Lavorgna, the Tone Audio reviewer, etc.  Not bad at all Purrin!  I wish there was some way to tag a user as having "good ears".
     
  7. Dyaems
    its possible that those people are also "paid" to adverise the product. not sure whats the "payment" though, maybe a kiss from Meridian or something
     
  8. Tyll Hertsens Contributor
    ^^^I find that unlikely.  But I do wonder if they were using it as a headphone amp or not. It might be fine our of the line out.  Haven't read their reviews...maybe I should.
     
  9. Aerocraft67
    Quote:
     
    Lavorgna did most of his review with line out, amp, and, speakers, not headphones, on which he defers to Hertsens. He did this with Dragonfly and iDAC, too. More of a DAC-only evaluation. Connaker did more headphone evaluation, but some of it was with HD-600 (300 ohms), which should be less affected by the output Z. He also used some other 'phones that may well have been adversely affected by output Z that he didn't notice or report.
     
    Still dismayed to hear these results, even though my HD-650 should be more impervious to the ill effects--and of course this issue goes away when using the line out and separate amp. Not that I'm letting Meridian off the hook; it's a pretty bad decision not to disclose such a consequential design trade-off.
     
    Currawong likes this.
  10. TWIFOSP
    Quote:
     
    It would be fairly disingenuous to review a portable dac/amp as a dac only.  Defeats the purpose of having such a device if you have to carry another portable amp around.
     
  11. In the case of audiostream it could have to do with the politics of the stereophile network, which Tyll/IF is also part of.  
     
  12. Tyll Hertsens Contributor
    Quote:
     
    Not quite sure what you mean by that, but ML and I communicate very little.  Just see him a shows and stuff.  Generally, we each do what we think is right for our respective readers and really don't worry about cross-over of product.
     
  13. Aerocraft67
    Quote:
     
    Valid point for sure. But having shopped this subsegment carefully, I found that it's actually hard to find a current-generation DAC-only device at this price point. Dragonfly, iDAC, and Explorer all come with amps. Even though iFi sells an amp designed to pair with iDAC. You have to move over to Modi or Halide at different price points to get DAC only. And all accounts are that these are all competent DACs.
     
  14. What I was getting at (and aero seemed to imply as well) is that it would makes sense for Lavorgna not to focus on headphones as that seems to be your area while you would let him focus on something like digital downloads and DACs.  At least that's what it seems from reading both sites.
     
  15. Tyll Hertsens Contributor
    Ah. Yes we're both aware of each other. For example I'll be doing fewer desktop speakers, and when I do they'll be compact low-cost ones because I know ML would cover the bigger more expensive ones. I know that JA sends headphone inquiries my way a lot. So we work together in a loose sense. Something like the Explorer may get covered by all three, and that doesn't bother us as there will be some naturally occurring editorial slant for each.  
     
    I gotta say when I heard the Explorer today it with Senn Momentums (a 22 Ohm headphone) that it sounded remarkably loose and uncontrolled. 
     
First
 
Back
1 2 3
5 6 7 8 9 10
Next
 
Last

Share This Page