Tential
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2016
- Posts
- 128
- Likes
- 77
I do understand how I would have those issues if I was using a DAP that relies on folders for browsing. Since I don't use a DAP that relies on folders for browsing and instead scans the files metadata and organizes from there, it's more important for me to have correct metadata than folder organization (I need to fix my metadata badly one day). Either way, even if I ever did what you suggest, it would provide me zero benefit, since I would never browse my library like that anyway. I understand what you're saying regarding navigation though.Phew. Lots of questions. I'll do my best to help...
The "failure" of the curation/library manager typically looks like this: a failure to completely scan your library, or the scan will complete, but you'll find you have some missing album artwork, or you can't find a particular track from one album, because it shows up somewhere else, or not at all, or track titles, numbers, aren't displayed properly, etc. If you've never experienced this, perhaps you have a limited library where most of your content was purchased directly through the iTunes store? Most of us want more flexibility than that, because for one thing, iTunes purchases max out at 256 vbr AAC; Apple still don't offer lossless downloads. If iTunes/MediaMonkey haven't given you problems yet, it's only a matter of time... I absolutely 100% feel your pain in not wanting to curate your own library by folders. My entire music collection took a period of weeks to assemble like this, ripping from CD (and verifying and correcting via accurip). I promise that once it's done, it is not a step backwards! Because every DAP I've ever seen can happily navigate via folders. You don't have to do this to use a V30 (LG's native music app and most 3rd party music apps will also attempt to organize your library into categories). For me, manual folder organization was absolutely worth it, but I get why others want to just buy an iPhone X and live with a dongle and take the hit on the sound quality.
I've never kept a track of which apps have a playcount feature, because I've never used (and don't have a need of) such a feature. (FiiO's native music app has a "Most Played" section, but I don't see any play count.) Anybody else have any suggestions here?
MediaMonkey on FiiO would be different from MediaMonkey on the V30 because FiiO's DAPs can natively send all PCM tracks through FiiO's DAC hardware without any re-sampling. However, that doesn't mean the X5iii's overall SQ is going to be superior. The X5iii has a fairly noisy amp and I wouldn't consider it a step-up in SQ and it's definitely not a step-up in terms of the UI. FiiO's DAPs use an older version of Android, slower CPUs, smaller, lower-res screens. For the prices you quoted, the V30 would be the obvious choice for me.
I wouldn't say there is a right/wrong way, but the folder organization method is definitely more supported by the audiophile devices and understandably so. I'm definitely in the minority relying heavily on smart playlists, but I'm a data nerd and it's how I work. I wouldn't know what music I liked without the data lol.
I use itunes to manage my music, not to obtain it. Most of my music is 320 kbps. But once I'm done organizing my music I'll try to move to FLAC as much as possible, which is why I'm moving away from itunes. That, and I've broken a lot of ipods this past year. And itunes decided to automatically rate my own songs within the library manager, which messes with my smart playlists. I don't understand why itunes would think that's a feature so I want to move to MediaMonkey+Android DAP which seems like it will give me the same experience, with better SQ.
You've helped a lot though. My main concern was that I had ZERO options, which is always a sad place to be in. Instead I now know what I'm getting into. To sum it up:
The LGV30 is clearly the best phone I can get for music playback.
For my playback needs though, due to my app selection of needing an itunes like library manager that can be used between windows/android, I'm moving to MediaMonkey. To have a no compromises experience with MediaMonkey I need to look at a DAP in the range of the X7 Mark ii to have a similar experience with the LGV30.
It seems like you'd still take the LGV30 even with the resampling? Am I correct in that?
(unsure about this last bit here)
The resampling issue really won't effect me until I update my library to FLAC?
I guess I'm not really understanding what the difference between Resampling on the LGV30 and Native Playback on the X7Markii(HiBy R6 is what I'd probably purchase to have the best android experience) and what the SQ difference would be like.
Last edited: