Hey
@MusicalDoc8 ,
This is in reference to the LCD-5 review you just posted. I would have posted it as a comment but comments are limited to less characters than I needed to use to reply...so I am posting here.
I enjoyed your review! As well as many of your other posts I've read! It seems you are very impressed and satisfied with your extreme purchase and seemingly extreme enjoyment of your purchase.
As you may already know from the LCD-X and XC Update forum, that I own both of those and I think you own an XC if memory serves. I have a question as regards your comparison to either of those.
My main reservation in making the $4500 leap for an LCD-5, besides the rather significant price difference between the LCD-5 and the LCD-X or XC is the bass of the LCD-5.
As I am a recording engineer and mastering engineer for most genres of music ranging from classical to jazz, pop, and EDM particularly Dubstep, very strong sub-bass representation is of upmost importance to me as I will swap from my X and XC to my external monitors and sub-woofer (a 550watt SVS that is rated down to16Hz)...so it is important that my headphones represent the sub-bass as best they can to that which my external setup provides in spades.
So, finally my questions are how does the LCD-5 represent sub-bass at least down to 20hz?...as compared to the X or XC (i don't know if you own both). Also, if it is not as representative of those low frequencies, does the "detail" as you call it, make up for the extreme price hike up?...and perhaps less sub-bass (maybe due to the smaller drivers and thinner diaphragm)?
Also, have you tried EQing it at all? And if so, how does it respond to EQ? Can a potential lack of sub-bass be EQd in, or does the physical composition of the LCD-5 limit that aspect no matter how much you EQ (perhaps due to its smaller diaphragm)?
From my experience with the clarity and resolution of the Focal Stellia, I've come to appreciate a higher price bracket of headphone, though the Stellia cannot compete with either the LCD-X or XC in sub-bass at all and are useless in accurately mixing and mastering anything that has significant sub-bass...and the Stellia has a "metallic" shimmer sound quality that can't be EQd out, I think due to the Beryllium drivers it's made out of. But I do love its resolution for vocals...what I'm trying to say is that I can believe your review when you speak of detail as I think I've experienced a bit of that detail you speak of in the Stellia which is not quite as expensive as the LCD-5 (Stellia is $3000...kinda called the cheaper and "easier to drive (portable) Utopia"), but it may come close. And if the LCD-5 is even better than that, then let me just say, I drool at the thought of getting my hands on one of those.
$4500 is a lot of money for me, especially as I am on a tight budget (living in Hawaii is expensive) and other things like getting LASIK (laser corrective eye surgery, $2500) seem like a very inviting priority to me right now as I hate wearing glasses especially in front of my six monitors (glare, smudges, shifting my eyes from monitor to monitor, etc. don't do well with glasses). But I've been pondering and researching the LCD-5 ever since it came out...it sounds like a dream come true...but $4500! (sigh)
Please give me your thoughts if you have the time and inclination!
Blessings,
-Jonne