- Joined
- Mar 20, 2013
- Posts
- 16,646
- Likes
- 12,458
I am wondering about this too for my Andromeda S and Solaris. @iFi audio
We rate our headphone amplifiers as '16 ohm compatible' as with this load they achieve specified performance in terms of distortion and power.
All our headphone amplifiers are short circuit proof, meaning even a dead short will not damage them (but may trip protection circuitry).
The following interactions of load and amplifier are absolutely not unique to iFi products, but apply universally to ALL and ANY amplifiers on the market, speaker amplifiers as much as headphone amplifiers.
One consequence of using loads lower than specified minimum is that maximum output power is reduced below specification, as the amplifier will limit the output current.
Another is that for every halving of the load impedance distortion at low power levels is approximately tripled, with a given constant level. Modern amplifiers have a reasonably constant level of harmonic distortion nearly up to clipping, where the amplifier runs out of either current or voltage to drive the output.
So lowering load impedance below the specified minimum increases distortion, possibly significantly; if we'll go say from 16 ohms to 4 ohms, then distortion goes up appx. 9 times.
How such increase in distortion is interpreted and heard subjectively is a different subject. And if such increased distortion is audible but substantially below the distortion of the transducer/headphone is yet another.
A popular and fairly expensive IEM is officially listed by the manufacturer as 12.8 ohm @ 1kHz impedance and 112.8dB @ 1mW (normalised 132dB/1V).
The real measured impedance is around 4 ohms below 300Hz with 7.5 ohms at 1kHz and 21-24 ohms from 7khz to around 10kHz. The real measured SPL at 1V is 141.5dB.
Ignoring the sources of the discrepancies (which can be explained by different systems of rating rather than ill will and deception by the manufacturer as is commonly asserted in conspiracy theories), this IEM will be extremely challenging for ANY headphone amplifier and it will be hard to find a decent match.
First, the very high sensitivity will emphasize hiss/noise. Typical high quality headphone amplifiers can be made to have around 3uV output noise, or -110dB/1V and > 3V output. With the 141.5dB/1V sensitivity, such a noise levels means the noise itself is over 30dB in absolute level and clearly audible (and may even be intrusive) while the 3V output allow SPL of up to 150dB which is likely to damage ones hearing.
The second factor is that the low impedance will increase the distortion of the driving amplifier (iFi or our esteemed competitors) in the bass nearly tenfold while in the midrange it will be triple that specified for a 16 ohms load.
One option may be to manufacture a dedicated amplifier for such kind of IEMs, which should offer 0.3uV (-130dB/1V) output noise and a maximum of 0.3V output into 4 ohms at low distortion + low output impedance and has a maximum gain of appx. -10dB. As a 300 ohms resistor produced more noise than -130dB/1V making such an amplifier would require very extreme design to achieve the required specifications and may still require cooling with liquid nitrogen to achieve the required specification.
Instead at iFi we have specifically developed the iEMatch (integrated in some products and available standalone for others (and for those of our esteemed competitors) to address this problem and make such IEMs more compatible with typical headphone amplifiers. Using iEMatch (which retails for less than 5% of the cost of the IEM in question) we achieve two things.
The sensitivity of the IEM is reduced to 117.5dB/1V meaning noise levels of 3uV (-110dB/1V) now only produce a SPL of 7.5dB, at the very edge of audibility and maximum SPL is a still very unhealthy 127.5dB, which however is an order of magnitude less damaging to the human hearing than 151.5dB.
Secondly, the minimum impedance seen by the amplifier is increased to 15.8 ohms, is 15.9 ohms at 1kHz and 16 ohms at 7-10khz. This means that it will be easily driven within the specified performance by an amplifier rated for 16 ohms loads, while the load itself sees a source impedance of less than 1 ohm, comparable to a direct connection.
So it is not required to use iEMatch to avoid damage to the xCAN or to get sound when using ultra high sensitivity/ultra low impedance IEMs/headphones.
However, in the interest of hearing protection as well as pleasurable listening with music (lower noise, lower distortion) we STRONGLY recommend that IEMs and headphones of both very high sensitivity AND very low impedances are used with our iEMatch.
This dramatically improves compatibility of such IEMs with a wide range of amplifiers (not just ours!) and usually costs a small fraction of the cost of the IEM or headphone in question.
Stay updated on iFi audio at their sponsor profile on Head-Fi.
|