productred
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2006
- Posts
- 1,121
- Likes
- 804
Today I went to buy a Onkyo dp-x1a but is a demo unit as no more new set. I still cannot find any of my daps that match well with my CE-5. Why?
Yesterday night, I listen to it using wm1a and I find the timber for the piano is not right as it is thin. It seems the range from 200-500hz is lower so it does not have much body to the piano sound. I use Sony xba-z5 to compare with CE-5 and the z5 sounds more true even though my z5 still not burn-in much. I like to use piano music to test as my daughter is learning piano so I know how the timber for piano sound.
Today, I went to the shop where I buy the Hyla and I use my memory of yesterday listening to compare to Onkyo using the same track. At once, I fall in love with CE-5 again. The synergy of CE-5 and dp-x1a is just right matching.
I'm a semi-pro pianist and keyboardist who has about 30 years experience on the instrument, and I found the CE-5/WM1A replay of piano fairly realistic with good weight and timbre. Not the most accurate, definitely not for reference, but definitely not thin. The inner accoustic of classical piano shone through. I love the Z5 - see my posts on the Z5 thread - but the Z5 has TOO MUCH weight on piano notes than the real thing. So is my MH335DWSR. The CE-5 does shows a more lay-back lo-mid range - and some male vocals may sound a tad thinner, but for the resonance and ringing of the piano it does fairly well. Rather than thin I'd describe it as a tad sweeter tone than reference. Of course if you ask me I'd prefer my UERR for critical listening on classical tracks anyday.
I've tried the CE-5 on my old DP-x1 and also found some good synergy, but prefer that of the WM1A. My WM1Z also works well, maybe even better than my WM1A on low gain. My preference is still WM1A on high gain, balanced.